Interface and Features
File recovery features
- 2023
- 2022
- 2021
- 2020
- 2019
- 2018
- 2017
- 2016
- 2015
- 2014
File recovery using file signatures (raw file recovery)
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
DiskInternals Uneraser | 5.0 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for can be selected. Also it’s possible to specify where files to search for: the entire disk or free space. This recovery is invoked by the Recover More Files (Recovered by signatures) button. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. The feature can be turned on and off. File types to search for cannot be selected. Found files are shown in a separate tab Extra Found Files. | |
TogetherShare Data Recovery | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. Found files appear in the Special lost files (Label) and More lost files (RAW) section. | |
R-Undelete | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. | |
SysTools Hard Drive Recovery Tool | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. Found files appear in the Raw Files section. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. Found files are shown in a special section: File Name Lost | |
Disk Drill | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. Found files appear in the Found files and Reconstructed / Reconstructed labeled sections. Some new file types have been added | |
Speed Data Recovery | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. Found files appear in the Files found section. | |
All programs have this feature, which is necessary when recovering files from severely damaged file systems. Uneraser allows its users to select which file types will be searched for. Since our last review: EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard: the section for raw files has been renamed to File Name Lost. Disk Drill: some new file types have been added. |
Deep analysis of disks (disk scan)
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
R-Undelete | 5.5 | Two separate scan modes: Show Files to find more lost files on existing logical disks and Deep Scan for partitions to find lost files on unrecognized and unallocated spaces on hard drives. No scan parameters can be specified. Scan results are automatically stored in a file and automatically loaded when another file recovery sessions starts with the same hard drive. Scan info files are automatically deleted in a certain amount of time. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.5 | A versatile scan parameter set. Disks can be scanned partially. Scan process can be paused and then resumed. Scan results are shown on separate tabs, like Drive – Deleted files, Lost Partition Files, Extra Files, etc. Scan results can be stored in a file after the scan is completed and may be loaded later. | |
Disk Drill | 5.0 | Scan types can be selected: Quick Scan, Deep Scan, Search for lost partitions, Allocate existing data, Undelete protected data, and All recovery methods. While scanning, the program starts showing the number and types for found files in the Pictures, Video, Audio, Documents, and Archives folders. Scan can be stopped and then resumed. Scan results can be connected as a disk (the Show scan results in Explorer command). Bad sectors are shown in the program log. Scan results are automatically saved and may be loaded automatically. Already found files can be recovered even before scan completion | |
Speed Data Recovery | 4.5 | A drive object to scan can be specified. Also there’s an option to Select Location – Scanning Snapshots, Directory, Desktop, Image, Recycle bin. Scan be paused and then resumed. Two sections appear after disk scan: Normal files and Files found (apparently raw files). Scan results can be saved and then loaded. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.0 | Drive objects to scan and file types to search for can be specified. Scan results cannot be saved. | |
DiskInternals Uneraser | 4.0 | A drive object to scan can be specified: A drive or partition, and common folders (Documents, Pictures, Desktop). Scan results cannot be saved. | |
TogetherShare Data Recovery | 4.0 | Drive objects (Desktop, a hard drive, a partition) can be selected for scan. Disk scan can be paused and then resumed. Scan results can be exported and imported. | |
SysTools Hard Drive Recovery Tool | 4.0 | Only disk partitions can be selected for scan. Two scan modes are available: Scan and Formatted Scan. Scan results are saved automatically. The program asks about loading the scan results. | |
All tested programs support deep analysis of disks (disk scan), which is necessary to recover files from disks with damaged file systems. EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard has the best set of scan parameters. The rest of the programs can only provide their users with some basic scan options. All but two programs save scan results, the exceptions are Uneraser and Raise Data Recovery. Since our last review: Disk Drill: Already found files can be recovered even before scan completion. Speed Data Recovery: a new object for scan has been added: Recycle bin |
File systems supported for file recovery
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
DiskInternals Uneraser | 6.0 | FAT12/16/32, exFAT, NTFS, NTFS5, ReFS, APFS(reader), HFS+, Ext2/3/4, UFS, XFS and ZFS, RomFS(reader). | |
Raise Data Recovery | 6.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS, ReFS/ReFS3, HFS+, APFS (with trial limitations), ext2/3/4, ReiserFS, XFS, JFS (with trial limitations). | |
Disk Drill | 5.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS, HFS/HFS+, APFS, ext3/4. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.5 | FAT(FAT12, FAT16, FAT32), exFAT, NTFS, NTFS5, ReFS, ext2, ext3, HFS+ | |
Speed Data Recovery | 5.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, HFS+, ext2/3 | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, ReFS | |
TogetherShare Data Recovery | 5.0 | FAT 12/16/32, exFAT, NTFS, NTFS 5, ext 2/3/4. | |
SysTools Hard Drive Recovery Tool | 4.0 | FAT 16/32, exFAT, NTFS, HFS+ | |
All programs support standard Windows file systems: FAT, NTFS, and the exFAT file system, a file system that is a de-facto standard for a multi-platform environment (Windows, Mac, Linux). All but three programs support Mac and Linux file systems, which are required for recovering files from Mac computers and various NAS devices. Uneraser, Raise Data Recovery, and Disk Drill support the new APFS file system from Apple. Raise Data Recovery and Uneraser have the largest sets of supported file systems, while SysTools Data Recovery supports only basic Windows file systems. |
Disk imaging and copying
If there is physical damage or a mechanical failure on a hard drive, the process of reading from the disk can cause further data loss. As a result, creating an image of the disk before performing any file recovery tasks is the preferred best practice. This allows you to run multiple data recovery attempts on the image without causing further deterioration of the drive. This is crucial if you need to bring it to a professional data recovery company after a failed DIY attempt.
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
R-Undelete | 5.5 | Image types: compressed. No image parameters can be specified. The program can open other image file types, like dsk. | |
DiskInternals Uneraser | 5.5 | File formats for disk images: dsk and img. There’s an option Create Images for All Stories that can create several images in one task. An image for a certain disk area can be created. | |
Disk Drill | 5.0 | A drive backup can be created as a dmg file. The dmg file format is native to Mac computers and cannot be connected to Windows systems without third-party software. The program can also create byte-to-byte images. Images can be opened in the program to recover files from such images. Bad sectors are shown in the program log. An image can be created for a disk region | |
Speed Data Recovery | 3.0 | The program only can open disk images. | |
TogetherShare Data Recovery | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
SysTools Hard Drive Recovery Tool | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
R-Undelete, Disk Drill, and Uneraser can create disk images. Speed Data Recovery can only load images. Since our last review: Disk Drill: Bad sectors are shown in the program log. An image can be created for a disk region. |
File search, mark for recovery, sorting
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Disk Drill | 5.5 | Files can be shown as All files, Deleted or Lost, Existing, Reconstructed Manual marking for recovery, sorting by clicking column names and Ascending / Descending. Search parameters: individual file search, file mask search, size search. Files can be filtered by their size and new parameters can be applied: Larger than, Less than, Interval, by Date Modified: Today, Yesterday, This week, This month, This year, and Advanced, or within the last: Exactly, Before, After, Interval (days, weeks, months, years), by file types: All files, Pictures, Video, etc. The Recover All button marks all files. Also files can be sorted by Files, Files and icons, Folders, Folders and icons. A Recovery chances filter can be applied: High, Average, Low, Unknown. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.5 | Search parameters: individual file / folder search / mark for recovery, file mask search / manual mark for recovery. File sorting by file extension, time, and size by clicking column names, buttons for most popular file types. Found files are appeared in a separate tab Search. Files can be shown in Large icons and Details. The program has two typed of filters: Filter (Lost Files, Recent Files, pictures, music, etc.) and Advanced Filter (files deleted and existing, file types, time stamps, size, the first letter, etc.). Search results are shown directly in the folder/file tree. Files can be viewed as All, Lost, Existing and sorted as Ascending, Descending, etc | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | Sorting by names, paths, sizes, dates, or deleted/existing. Special tabs for most common file types. Files can be sorted by clicking column names. Search for individual files and file masks. Files can be shown in List View, Tree View, and Tiles View (for pictures). Medium / Large tiles for graphic files. Files can be sorted by their chances for successful recovery. | |
Speed Data Recovery | 4.0 | Files can be sorted by their Path, Type, Created Date, and Modified Date. Objects can be shown as an object list or as icons. The list can be sorted by clicking column names. Files can be filtered by their names, size, creation, and modification times. | |
DiskInternals Uneraser | 4.0 | Files can be shown as Thumbnails, Tiles, Icons, List, or Details. Files can be sorted by clicking column titles. File search has the following options: Search This Disk, Search the Current Folder, Photos, Pictures, Movies, and Documents. Files can be selected for recovery manually using the mouse, and the Shift and Ctrl buttons. | |
TogetherShare Data Recovery | 3.5 | Files can be shown as Large icons or Details. Sorting can be performed by clicking column titles. Files can be searched for by using a search string and ordered by file Type, Path, Time. | |
SysTools Hard Drive Recovery Tool | 3.5 | Files can be filtered as Photos, Audios, Videos, Emails, and more, and they are searchable with a search pattern and date (Created, Modified, Last Access). Sorting is made by clicking column titles. Marking for recovery is manual. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 3.5 | Individual file and file mask search. Files can be sorted by clicking column names, manual mark for recovery. | |
All evaluated programs have quite advanced file search capabilities, which is essential when sifting through hundreds or thousands of recovered files. EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard, and Disk Drill for Windows have the best file search, sorting, and recovery mark options, yet optimized for inexperienced users. TogetherShare Data Recovery and SysTools Data Recovery and Raise Data Recovery have the minimum set of search and mark options. Since our last review: EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard and Disk Drill have new search and show options. |
S.M.A.R.T.
S.M.A.R.T., which stands for Self-Monitoring, Analysis and Reporting Technology, is a widely-used technology in hard drives and solid-state devices that monitors various reliability conditions and predicts possible hardware failures.
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
R-Undelete | 6.0 | Disk icons show general disk’s S.M.A.R.T. status. S.M.A.R.T. attributes can be shown in a pop-up window. If bad S.M.A.R.T. data is present, the program shows a warning sign. | |
Disk Drill | 6.0 | Disk health status is shown using initial S.M.A.R.T. disk health monitoring. Settings of S.M.A.R.T. attribute display can be changed, disk temperature can be shown, and there’s the Show status in system tray option. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
Speed Data Recovery | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
DiskInternals Uneraser | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
SysTools Hard Drive Recovery Tool | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
TogetherShare Data Recovery | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
Only two programs, R-Undelete and Disk Drill for Windows have S.M.A.R.T. attribute monitoring. |
Logging
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Disk Drill | 5.0 | The log is automatically saved to the dd.log file. It can be viewed through the Disk Drill for Windows logs command. | |
DiskInternals Uneraser | 4.5 | The log can be shown (the Show Log command). The log can be saved and cleared. There’s an option Export Date during file recovery. | |
R-Undelete | 4.5 | Log shows which files were successfully recovered and which file recoveries failed. The log can be saved to a file. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.5 | Standard logging capabilities. The log can be saved to an htm file. | |
SysTools Hard Drive Recovery Tool | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
TogetherShare Data Recovery | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
Speed Data Recovery | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
Only 4 programs have logging capabilities. Disk Drill has extensive logging features. |
File recovery parameters
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
DiskInternals Uneraser | 5.0 | Three options are available: recovered files can be saved, mounted into a file system, and uploaded to an ftp site. Also there are three options available for saving files: Save directory structure, Extract file date from metadata, and Skip symbolic links. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 5.0 | Recovers filenames and the folder structure. Existing files can be overwritten, renamed, or skipped. It’s possible to open the folder with recovered files upon completion of the recovery process. The program preserves Hidden and System file attributes. | |
R-Undelete | 4.5 | Recovers filenames and the folder structure. Alternatively, it can recover files to their file types. The program opens the folder with recovered files upon completion of the recovery process. | |
TogetherShare Data Recovery | 4.5 | Recovers filenames and the folder structure. | |
Disk Drill | 4.5 | Recovers filenames and the folder structure. It’s possible to open the folder with recovered files upon completion of the recovery process. | |
Speed Data Recovery | 4.5 | Recovers filenames and the folder structure. It’s possible to open the folder with recovered files upon completion of the recovery process. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.5 | Recovers filenames and the folder structure. It’s possible to open the folder with recovered files upon completion of the recovery process. | |
SysTools Hard Drive Recovery Tool | 3.0 | There are 2 recovery options: Save All Data and Save Deleted Data. It’s unclear how to recover only marked files. Another ambiguous option is Don’t Save Recovered Deleted Data. Its outcome is obscure. | |
All programs recover filenames and the folder structure. Uneraser has an interesting option: Skip symbolic links, which is usually present in professional data recovery programs. |
File recovery using file signatures (raw file recovery)
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
R-Undelete | 5.0 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for can be selected from a predefined set. | |
Disk Drill for Windows | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. Found files appear in the Found files and Reconstructed / Reconstructed labeled sections. | |
iBoysoft Data Recovery | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. A new option RAWDriveRecovery has been added to turn this file recovery method on and off. | |
Speed Data Recovery | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. Found files appear in the Files found section. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. The feature can be turned on and off. File types to search for cannot be selected. Found files are shown in a separate tab Extra Found Files. Some new file types have been added. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. Found files are shown in a special section: Files Lost Original Name. | |
iBeesoft Data Recovery | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. Found files appear in the Files Lost Original Name section. | |
Aiseesoft Data Recovery | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. Found files appear in file type folders like Documents, Archive, etc. They contain both conventional and raw files. | |
All programs have this feature which is necessary when recovering files from severely damaged file systems. SFWare Data Recovery has a built-in file signature editor that allows the user to add and edit custom-defined file types. Since our last review: Raise Data Recovery: some new file types have been added. EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard: the folder with raw files has changed its name to Files Lost Original Name. iBoysoftDataRecovery: A new option RAW Drive Recovery has been added. |
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Raise Data Recovery | 6.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS, ReFS/ReFS3, HFS+, APFS (with trial limitations), ext2/3/4, ReiserFS, XFS, JFS (with trial limitations). | |
Disk Drill for Windows | 5.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS, HFS/HFS+, APFS, ext3/4. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, ReFS, HFS+, ext2/3, | |
iBeesoft Data Recovery | 5.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, HFS+, ext2/3 | |
iBoysoft Data Recovery | 5.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, HFS+, ext2/3 | |
Speed Data Recovery | 5.0 | AT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, HFS+, ext2/3 | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, ReFS | |
Aiseesoft Data Recovery | 4.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS | |
All programs support standard Windows file systems: FAT, NTFS, and the exFAT file system, a file system that is the default standard for a multi-platform environment (Windows, Mac, Linux). R-Undelete, Raise Data Recovery, and EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard support the new Windows ReFS file system. All but two programs support Mac and Linux file systems, which are required for recovering files from Mac computers and various NAS devices. Raise Data Recovery and Disk Drill for Windows support the new APFS file system from Apple. Raise Data Recovery has the largest sets of supported file systems, while AiseesoftDataRecovery and iBoysoftDataRecovery only support the basic Windows file system. Since our last review: Raise Data Recovery supports now the ReFS and ReFS3 file systems. |
Deep analysis of disks (disk scan)
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
R-Undelete | 5.5 | Two separate scan modes: Deep Scan to find more lost files on existing logical disks, and Show Files for partitions to find lost files on unrecognized and unallocated spaces on hard drives. No scan parameters can be specified. Scan results are automatically stored in a file and automatically loaded when another file recovery sessions starts with the same hard drive. Scan info files are automatically deleted in a certain amount of time. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.5 | A versatile scan parameter set. Disks can be scanned partially. Scan process can be paused and then resumed. Scan results are shown on separate tabs, like Drive – Deleted files, Lost Partition Files, Extra Files, etc. Scan results can be stored in a file after the scan is completed and may be loaded later. | |
Disk Drill for Windows | 5.0 | Scan types can be selected: Quick Scan, Deep Scan, Search for lost partitions, Allocate existing data, Undelete protected data, and All recovery methods. While scanning, the program starts showing the number and types for found files in the Pictures, Video, Audio, Documents, and Archives folders. Scan can be stopped and then resumed. Scan results can be connected as a disk (the Show scan results in Explorer command). Bad sectors are shown in the program log. | |
iBoysoft Data Recovery | 4.5 | An object to scan can be selected. Two scan modes are available: Simple Scan and Deep Scan. There’s a specific option FindMorePartitions for entire hard drives. Scan results are automatically saved and then loaded. | |
Speed Data Recovery | 4.5 | A drive object to scan can be specified. Also there’s an option Select Location – Scanning Snapshots, Directory, Desktop, Image. Scan be paused and then resumed. Two sections appear after disk scan: Normal files and Files found (apparently raw files). Scan results can be saved and then loaded. | |
Aiseesoft Data Recovery | 4.5 | File types to recover (images, video, etc) and recovery types (deleted data, a formatted partitions, etc.) can be selected. Two scan types can be applied: Quick Scan and Deep Scan. Found files can be shown as a list, as file types or icons. Scan results can be saved and opened later. | |
iBeesoft Data Recovery | 4.0 | A drive object (partition) can be selected. Two scan types are available: Quick Scan and Advanced Scan. File types to search for (images, audio, video, etc.) can be selected. Scan process can be paused and then resumed, but cannot be saved. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.0 | Drive objects to scan and file types to search for can be specified. Scan results cannot be saved. | |
All tested programs support deep analysis of disks (disk scan), which is necessary to recover files from disks with damaged file systems. EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard has the best set of scan parameters. R-Undelete has the most balanced scan process - it’s simple for inexperienced users yet provides all necessary options to recover files from both existing and lost logical disks. The rest of the programs can only provide their users with some basic scan options. All but two programs save scan results, the exceptions are iBeesoftDataRecovery and Raise Data Recovery. Since our last review: Disk Drill for Windows: Bad sectors are shown in the program log. iBoysoftDataRecovery: Scan results are saved automatically. |
File search, mark for recovery, sorting
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
R-Undelete | 5.0 | Sorting by names, paths, sizes, dates, or deleted/existing. Special tabs for most common file types. Files can be sorted by clicking column names. Search for individual files and file masks. Files can be shown in List View, Tree View, and Tiles View (for pictures). Medium / Large tiles for graphic files. Files can be sorted by their chances for successful recovery. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.0 | Search parameters: individual file / folder search / mark for recovery, file mask search / manual mark for recovery. File sorting by file extension, time, and size by clicking column names, buttons for most popular file types. Found files are appeared in a separate tab Search. Files can be shown in Large icons and Details. The program has two typed of filters: Filter (Lost Files, Recent Files, pictures, music, etc.) and Advanced Filter (files deleted and existing, file types, time stamps, size, the first letter, etc.). Search results are shown directly in the folder/file tree. | |
Disk Drill for Windows | 5.0 | Manual marking for recovery, sorting by clicking column names and Ascending / Descending. Search parameters: individual file search, file mask search, size search. Files can be filtered by their size (by selecting fixed sizes 0 KB, 128 KB, 512 KB, 1 MB, etc ,) by deleted within the last (any time, 1 day, 3 day, etc.), by file types: All files, Pictures, Video, etc. The Recover All button marks all files. Also files can be sorted by Files, Files and icons, Folders, Folders and icons. A new filter parameter has been added: Recovery chances (High, Average, Low, Unknown). | |
Aiseesoft Data Recovery | 4.0 | A search string Enter Name or Path here to search for individual files, folders, or file/folder masks. Files can be filtered by their extensions, size (minimum / maximum), or creation / modification date. Manual file marking for recovery. Files are sorted by clicking column names. Files are shown by their thumbnails, list, and content. Content in the left pane can be shown as TypeList or PathList. | |
iBoysoft Data Recovery | 4.0 | Manual search and mark for recovery, and the Show all files, Only show deleted files, and Only show existing files options. Files can be sorted by clicking column names. | |
Speed Data Recovery | 4.0 | Files can be sorted by their Path, Type, Created Date, and Modified Date. Objects can be shown as an object list or as icons. The list can be sorted by clicking column names. Files can be filtered by their names, size, creation, and modification times. | |
iBeesoft Data Recovery | 3.5 | A search string (Search file or folders) lets you search for individual files or folders. Search results are shown in read in the folder/file tree. Manual file marking for recovery. Files are sorted by clicking column names. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 3.5 | Individual file and file mask search. Files can be sorted by clicking column names, manual mark for recovery. | |
All evaluated programs have quite advanced file search capabilities, which is essential when sifting through hundreds or thousands of recovered files. R-Undelete, EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard, and Disk Drill for Windows for Windows have the best file search, sorting, and recovery mark options while still remaining optimized for inexperienced users. Raise Data Recovery and iBeesoftDataRecovery have the minimum set of search and mark options. Since our last review: EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard shows search results directly in the folder/file tree. Disk Drill for Windows has a new filter parameter Recovery chances. |
S.M.A.R.T.
S.M.A.R.T., which stands for Self-Monitoring, Analysis and Reporting Technology, is a widely-used technology in hard drives and solid-state devices that monitors various reliability conditions and predicts possible hardware failures.
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
R-Undelete | 6.0 | Disk icons show general disk’s S.M.A.R.T. status. S.M.A.R.T. attributes can be shown in a pop-up window. If bad S.M.A.R.T. data is present, the program shows a warning sign. | |
Disk Drill for Windows | 5.5 | Disk health status is shown using initial S.M.A.R.T. disk health monitoring. Settings of S.M.A.R.T. attribute display can be changed, disk temperature can be shown, and there’s the Show status in system tray option. | |
iBoysoft Data Recovery | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
Speed Data Recovery | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
iBeesoft Data Recovery | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
Aiseesoft Data Recovery | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
Only two programs, R-Undelete and Disk Drill for Windows for Windows have S.M.A.R.T. attribute monitoring. Since our last review: Disk Drill for Windows: Settings of S.M.A.R.T. attribute display can be changed, disk temperature can be shown, and there’s the Show status in system tray option. |
Disk imaging and copying
If there is physical damage or mechanical failures on a hard drive, reading from the disk can cause further data loss. For this reason, creating an image of the disk before performing any file recovery tasks is the preferred best practice. This allows you to run multiple data recovery attempts on the image without causing further deterioration of the drive, in case you need to bring it to a professional data recovery company after a failed DIY attempt.
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
R-Undelete | 5.5 | Image types: compressed. No image parameters can be specified. The program can open other image file types, like .dsk. | |
Disk Drill for Windows | 5.0 | A drive backup can be created as a dmg file. The dmg file format is native to Mac computers and cannot be connected to Windows systems without third-party software. The program can also create byte-to-byte images. Images can be opened in the program to recover files from such images. Bad sectors are shown in the program log. | |
Speed Data Recovery | 3.0 | The program can open disk images. | |
iBeesoft Data Recovery | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
Aiseesoft Data Recovery | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
iBoysoft Data Recovery | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
Only R-Undelete, Disk Drill for Windows for Windows, and SFWare Data Recovery can create and load disk images. Disk Drill for Windows for Windows create images in the dmg file format native to Mac computers. Speed Data Recovery can load images created by other programs. Since our last review: Disk Drill for Windows shows bad sectors in the program log. |
Logging
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Raise Data Recovery | 5.0 | Versatile logging. The log can be saved to a file. | |
R-Undelete | 4.5 | Log shows which files were successfully recovered and which file recoveries failed. The log can be saved to a file. | |
Disk Drill for Windows | 4.5 | The log is automatically saved to the dd.log file. It can be viewed through the Disk Drill for Windows logs command. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
iBeesoft Data Recovery | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
Aiseesoft Data Recovery | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
iBoysoft Data Recovery | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
Speed Data Recovery | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
Only 3 programs we evaluated had logging features. Such logs show the list of successfully/unsuccessfully recovered files at a minimum. |
File recovery parameters
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Raise Data Recovery | 5.0 | Recovers filenames and the folder structure. Existing files can be overwritten, renamed, or skipped.It’s possible to open the folder with recovered files upon completion of the recovery process. The program preserves Hidden and System file attributes. | |
R-Undelete | 4.5 | Recovers filenames and the folder structure. Alternatively, it can recover files to their file types. The program opens the folder with recovered files upon completion of the recovery process. | |
iBeesoft Data Recovery | 4.5 | Recovers filenames and the folder structure. It’s possible to open the folder with recovered files upon completion of the recovery process. | |
Aiseesoft Data Recovery | 4.5 | Recovers filenames and the folder structure. It’s possible to open the folder with recovered files upon completion of the recovery process. | |
Disk Drill for Windows | 4.5 | Recovers filenames and the folder structure. It’s possible to open the folder with recovered files upon completion of the recovery process. | |
Speed Data Recovery | 4.5 | Recovers filenames and the folder structure. It’s possible to open the folder with recovered files upon completion of the recovery process. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.5 | Recovers filenames and the folder structure.It’s possible to open the folder with recovered files upon completion of the recovery process. | |
iBoysoft Data Recovery | 4.0 | Recovers filenames but not the folder structure. It’s possible to open the folder with recovered files upon completion of the recovery process. | |
All programs can recover file names, and all, except iBoysoftDataRecovery, recover the folder structure. Since our last review: Raise Data Recovery preserves Hidden and System file attributes. |
Disk imaging and copying
In cases where there is physical damage or mechanical failure on a hard drive, reading from the disk can cause further data loss. For this reason, creating an image of the disk before performing any file recovery tasks is a preferred best practice. This allows you to run multiple data recovery attempts on the image without causing further deterioration of the drive, in case you need to bring it to a professional data recovery company after a failed DIY attempt.
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
R-Undelete | 5.5 | Image types: compressed. No image parameters can be specified. The program can open other image file types like .dsk. | |
SFWare Data Recovery | 5.5 | The program can created and open disk image with the .img extension. | |
Disk Drill for Windows | 5.0 | A drive backup can be created as a dmg file. It can be opened in the program to recover files from such images. The dmg file format is native to Mac computers and cannot be connected to Windows systems without third-party software. | |
Speed Data Recovery | 4.5 | The program can open disk images. | |
Wise Data Recovery | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
iBoysoft Data Recovery | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
Only R-Undelete, Disk Drill for Windows, and SFWare Data Recovery can create and load disk images. Disk Drill for Windows create images in the dmg file format native to Mac computers. Speed Data Recovery can load images created by other programs. |
Deep analysis of disks (disk scan)
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Disk Drill for Windows | 5.0 | Scan types can be selected: Quick Scan, Deep Scan, Search for lost partitions, Allocate existing data, Undelete protected data, and All recovery methods. While scanning, the program starts showing the number and types for found files in the Pictures, Video, Audio, Documents, and Archives folders. Scan can be stopped and then resumed. Scan results can be connected as a disk (the Show scan results in Explorer command). | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | Two separate scan modes: Deep Scan to find more lost files on existing logical disks, and Show Files for partitions to find lost files on unrecognized and unallocated spaces on hard drives. No scan parameters can be specified. Scan results are automatically stored in a file and automatically loaded when another file recovery sessions starts with the same hard drive. Scan info files are automatically deleted in a certain amount of time. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.0 | A versatile scan parameter set. Disks can be scanned partially. Scan process can be paused and then resumed. Scan results are shown on separate tabs, like Drive – Deleted files, Lost Partition Files, Extra Files, etc. Scan results can be stored in a file after the scan is completed and may be loaded later. Deep scan is now called Advanced scan. | |
SFWare Data Recovery | 4.5 | The following scan types can be selected: Deleted File Recovery, Lost File Recovery; Recover Deleted Photos, Recover Lost Photos; Drive/Partition Recovery, and Formatted Recovery, depending on the recovery task. Then an object to scan can be selected and then a scan type: regular/raw search. If the regular scan doesn’t yield any results, a smart scan can be used. Two sections appear after disk scan: Data View and File Type View (apparently raw files). Scan results can be saved and then loaded. | |
Speed Data Recovery | 4.5 | A drive object to scan can be specified. Also there’s an option Select Location – Scanning Snapshots, Directory, Desktop, Image. Scan be paused and then resumed. Two sections appear after disk scan: Normal files and Files found (apparently raw files). Scan results can be saved and then loaded. | |
Wise Data Recovery | 4.5 | A drive object and a scan type can be selected: Quick Scan and Deep Scan. A scan process can be stopped and then resumed. 2 sections appeared after the scan: All files and More files (possibly raw files). Scan results cannot be saved. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.5 | Drive objects to scan and file types to search for can be specified. Scan results cannot be saved. | |
iBoysoft Data Recovery | 4.0 | An object to scan can be selected. Then a scan type can be selected: Disk scan/Deep scan. Scan results can be saved and then loaded. | |
All tested programs support deep analysis of disks (disk scan), which is necessary to recover files from disks with damaged file systems. EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard has the best set of scan parameters. R-Undelete has the most balanced scan process - it’s simple for inexperienced users yet provides all necessary options to recover files from both existing and lost logical disks. Since our last review: EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard: Deep scan is now called Advanced scan. |
Logging
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Raise Data Recovery | 4.5 | Versatile logging. The log can be saved to a file. | |
Disk Drill for Windows | 4.5 | The log is automatically saved to the dd.log file. It can be viewed through the Disk Drill logs command. | |
R-Undelete | 4.5 | Log shows which files were successfully recovered and which file recoveries failed. The log can be saved to a file. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
Speed Data Recovery | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
Wise Data Recovery | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
iBoysoft Data Recovery | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
SFWare Data Recovery | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
Only 3 programs we evaluated had logging features. Such logs show at least the list of successfully/unsuccessfully recovered files. |
File recovery parameters
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
SFWare Data Recovery | 5.0 | Recovers filenames and the folder structure. Already existing files can be overwritten, renamed, or skipped. Invalid filenames can also be processed. Recovered files can be zipped with different compression levels. Recovered data can be written directly to a CD/DVD disc. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.5 | Recovers filenames and the folder structure. Existing files can be overwritten, renamed, or skipped. It’s possible to open the folder with recovered files upon completion of the recovery process. | |
R-Undelete | 4.5 | Recovers filenames and the folder structure. Alternatively, it can recover files to their file types. The program opens the folder with recovered files upon completion of the recovery process. | |
Speed Data Recovery | 4.0 | Recovers filenames and the folder structure. It’s possible to open the folder with recovered files upon completion of the recovery process. | |
Wise Data Recovery | 4.0 | Recovers filenames and the folder structure. | |
Disk Drill for Windows | 4.0 | Recovers filenames and the folder structure. It’s possible to open the folder with recovered files upon completion of the recovery process. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.0 | Recovers filenames and the folder structure. It’s possible to open the folder with recovered files upon completion of the recovery process. | |
iBoysoft Data Recovery | 4.0 | Recovers filenames and the folder structure. It’s possible to open the folder with recovered files upon completion of the recovery process. | |
All programs can recover filenames and the folder structure. SFWare Data Recovery has the best file recovery parameter set, can process already existing files, compress recovered files, and write them directly to a CD/DVD disc. |
S.M.A.R.T.
S.M.A.R.T., which stands for Self-Monitoring, Analysis and Reporting Technology, is used in hard drives and solid-state devices to monitor various reliability conditions and predicts possible hardware failures.
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
R-Undelete | 6.0 | Disk icons show general disk’s S.M.A.R.T. status. S.M.A.R.T. attributes can be shown in a pop-up window. If bad S.M.A.R.T. data is present, the program shows a warning sign. | |
Disk Drill for Windows | 5.0 | Disk health status is shown using initial S.M.A.R.T. disk health monitoring. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
iBoysoft Data Recovery | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
SFWare Data Recovery | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
Speed Data Recovery | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
Wise Data Recovery | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
Only two programs, R-Undelete and Disk Drill for Windows have S.M.A.R.T. attribute monitoring. |
File recovery using file signatures (raw file recovery)
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
SFWare Data Recovery | 6.0 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for can be selected, added, deleted, and edited. Found files appear in the File Types section. | |
Speed Data Recovery | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. Found files appear in the Files found section. | |
Wise Data Recovery | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. Found files appear in the More files section. | |
R-Undelete | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. The feature can be turned on and off. File types to search for cannot be selected. Found files are shown in a separate tab Extra Found Files. | |
Disk Drill for Windows | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. Found files appear in the Found files and Reconstructed / Reconstructed labeled sections. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. Found files are shown in a special section: RAW (after Advanced Scan). | |
iBoysoft Data Recovery | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. Found files appear in the Raw Files section. | |
All programs have this feature, which is necessary when recovering files from severely damaged file systems. SFWare Data Recovery has a built-in file signature editor that allows the user to add and edit custom-defined file types. Since our last review: EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard: Found files are shown in a special section: RAW (after Advanced Scan). Disk Drill for Windows: A new section for raw files Reconstructed labeled was added. |
File search, mark for recovery, sorting
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Disk Drill for Windows | 5.0 | Manual marking for recovery, sorting by clicking column names and Ascending / Descending. Search parameters: individual file search, file mask search, size search. Files can be filtered by their size (by selecting fixed sizes 0 KB, 128 KB, 512 KB, 1 MB, etc ,) by deleted within the last (any time, 1 day, 3 day, etc.), by file types: All files, Pictures, Video, etc. The Recover All button marks all files. Also files can be sorted by Files, Files and icons, Folders, Folders and icons. | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | Sorting by names, paths, sizes, dates, or deleted/existing. Special tabs for most common file types. Files can be sorted by clicking column names. Search for individual files and file masks. Files can be shown in List View, Tree View, and Tiles View (for pictures). Medium / Large tiles for graphic files. Files can be sorted by their chances for successful recovery. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.0 | Search parameters: individual file / folder search / mark for recovery, file mask search / manual mark for recovery. File sorting by file extension, time, and size by clicking column names, buttons for most popular file types. Found files are appeared in a separate tab Search. Files can be shown in Large icons and Details. The program has two typed of filters: Filter (Lost Files, Recent Files, pictures, music, etc.) and Advanced Filter (files deleted and existing, file types, time stamps, size, the first letter, etc.). | |
SFWare Data Recovery | 4.5 | Search parameters: individual file search, file mask search (including Match case), size search, date search (Last Accessed, Created), files can be sorted by clicking column names. Files can be shown according to Data View or File Type View. Only deleted files can be shown. Manual mark for recovery and the Mark All and UnMark All buttons. | |
Speed Data Recovery | 4.5 | Files can be sorted by their Path, Type, Created Date, and Modified Date. Objects can be shown as an object list or as icons. The list can be sorted by clicking column names. Files can be filtered by their names, size, creation, and modification times. | |
Wise Data Recovery | 4.0 | Individual file and file mask search (Input Keyword). Files can be sorted by clicking column names, manual mark for recovery. There are several shortcut menu commands for automatic marking for recovery: Select All, Select None, and Invert Selection. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.0 | Individual file and file mask search. Files can be sorted by clicking column names, manual mark for recovery. | |
iBoysoft Data Recovery | 4.0 | Manual search and mark for recovery, and the Show all files, Only show deleted files, and Only show existing files options. Files can be sorted by clicking column names. | |
All evaluated programs have quite advanced file search capabilities, which is essential when sifting through hundreds or thousands of recovered files. R-Undelete, EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard, and Disk Drill for Windows have the best file search, sorting, and recovery mark options, yet they are all optimized for inexperienced users. Raise Data Recovery and Wise Data Recovery have the minimum set of search and mark options. |
File systems supported for file recovery
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Raise Data Recovery | 6.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, HFS+/APFS, Ext2/Ext3/Ext4FS, ReiserFS, XFS, JFS, | |
Disk Drill for Windows | 5.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS, HFS/HFS+, APFS, Ext2/3/4. | |
Wise Data Recovery | 5.5 | FAT, NTFS, HFS/HFS+/HFSX, Ext2/3 | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, ReFS, Ext2/3, HFS+ | |
SFWare Data Recovery | 5.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS, HFS/HFS+/HFSX, Ext2/3 | |
Speed Data Recovery | 5.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, Ext2/3, HFS+ | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, ReFS | |
iBoysoft Data Recovery | 3.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS. | |
All programs support standard Windows file systems: FAT and NTFS. Some support Mac and Linux file systems, which are required for recovering files from Mac computers and various NAS devices. Raise Data Recovery has the largest sets of supported file systems, although it doesn’t support ReFS; the file system that can be used in Windows Storage Space. Conversely, R-Undelete and EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard do support the new Windows ReFS file system. Wise Data Recovery and SFWare Data Recovery don’t support the exFAT file system, a file system that is a de-facto standard for many multi-platform environments (Windows, Mac, Linux). Since our last review: Disk Drill for Windows supports now the APFS file system. |
File systems supported for file recovery
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 6.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, ReFS, Ext2/3, HFS+ | |
Ontrack EasyRecovery | 5.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, (Ext2/3/4 and HFS/HFS+ in Toolkit) | |
Raise Data Recovery | 5.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, HFS+/APFS, UFS, Ext2/Ext3/Ext4FS, ReiserFS, XFS, JFS. | |
R-Undelete | 5.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, ReFS | |
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, ReFS, (Ext2/3/4 FS, USF1/UFS2, HFS/HFS+, and APFS in the Pro and Network version) | |
Disk Drill for Windows | 4.5 | FAT/exFAT , NTFS/NTFS5, Ext FS, HFS+ | |
Recuva | 4.0 | FAT/exFAT and NTFS/NTFS5 | |
Premium Recovery Software | 4.0 | FAT/exFAT and NTFS/NTFS5 | |
All programs support standard Windows file systems: FAT and NTFS. Some support Mac and Linux file systems, which are required for recovering files from Mac computers and various NAS devices. Raise Data Recovery has the largest sets of supported file systems, although it doesn’t support ReFS, the file system that can be used in Windows Storage Space. Restorer Ultimate, EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard, and R-Undelete support the Windows ReFS file system. If necessary, Restorer Ultimate can be upgraded to the PRO version which supports Mac OS (including APFS) and Linux file systems. Since our last review: Ontrack EasyRecovery Professional supports now the Ext2/3/4 and HFS/HFS+ file systems in its Toolkit. |
File recovery parameters
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Recovers hidden attributes, system attributes, alternative data streams for NTFS, security attributes for NTFS and metafiles. Files with the same names can be overwritten/renamed/skipped according to their time stamps, file sizes, etc. Bad sector processing can be specified. | |
Ontrack EasyRecovery | 5.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. All recovered files can be zipped (the zip file type archive). Deleted files/folders and files with certain extensions can be included/excluded to/from recovery. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.5 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Existing files can be overwritten, renamed, or skipped. | |
R-Undelete | 4.5 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Alternatively, it can recover files to their file types. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. | |
Recuva | 4.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. | |
Premium Recovery Software | 4.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. | |
Disk Drill for Windows | 4.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. | |
All programs can recover file names and the folder structure. Restorer Ultimate has the best file recovery parameter set and can recover various NTFS attributes. Since our last review: Ontrack EasyRecovery Professional can zip all recovered files. Deleted files/folders and files with certain extensions can be included/excluded to/from recovery. |
S.M.A.R.T.
S.M.A.R.T., which stands for Self-Monitoring, Analysis and Reporting Technology, is a widely-used technology in hard drives and solid-state devices that monitors various reliability conditions and predicts possible hardware failures.
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
R-Undelete | 6.0 | Disk icons show general disk’s S.M.A.R.T. status. S.M.A.R.T. attributes can be shown in a pop-up window. If bad S.M.A.R.T. data is present, the program shows a warning sign. | |
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Disk icons show general disk’s S.M.A.R.T. status. Shows hard drive’s S.M.A.R.T. attributes in a pop-up window. When attempting to work with a drive with bad S.M.A.R.T. data, the program throws a special warning that recommends performing data recover from an image. | |
Ontrack EasyRecovery | 5.5 | Disk health status, including S.M.A.R.T. attributes, can be seen using the Monitor Drive function. | |
Premium Recovery Software | 5.5 | Two types of S.M.A.R.T. tests can be conducted, Short (Recommended) which is a fast S.M.A.R.T. test with most critical parameters, sampling the device and Extended – an extended version of the S.M.A.R.T. test that covers the entire device. | |
Disk Drill for Windows | 5.0 | Disk health status is shown using initial S.M.A.R.T. disk health monitoring. | |
Recuva | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
Only three programs, EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard, Raise Data Recovery, and Recuva don’t have S.M.A.R.T. attribute monitoring. Restorer Ultimate and R-Undelete not only shows the S.M.A.R.T. attributes, it also throws special warnings when the user tries to recover files from a drive with hardware issues. In a DIY program, this is particularly helpful since beginner users may not know the risk of attempting data recovery on a failing hard drive. |
Disk parts/regions
Most programs require you to scan the entire disk. The ability to scan a specific region or disk part is normally an advanced feature for professional data recovery tools, but as hard drive capacities get larger and larger, this feature is extremely useful even for DIY data recovery. Limiting your scans to a specific disk part or region can greatly reduce your scan times when scanning larger disks.
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | Disk regions appear as objects that can be processed like regular disks. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No support for disk parts or regions. | |
Ontrack EasyRecovery | 0.0 | No support for disk parts or regions. A disk area can be specified for imaging in the Technician version. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 0.0 | No support for disk parts or regions. | |
Recuva | 0.0 | No support for disk parts or regions. | |
Premium Recovery Software | 0.0 | No support for disk parts or regions. | |
Disk Drill for Windows | 0.0 | No support for disk parts or regions. | |
R-Undelete | 0.0 | No support for disk parts or regions. | |
Only Restorer Ultimate has the region capabilities. |
File search, mark for recovery, sorting
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | Search parameters: “Show only deleted files”, “Show only existing files”, individual file search/mark for recovery, file mask (including mask presets), search/mark for recovery, file search for date (separately for modification, creation, last access), file search for size, file search for file ID. Files can be sorted by clicking column names. Files can be sorted and marked by their chances for successful recovery. The program shows detailed information about a selected file. Support for mass file recovery: file sorting by file extension, file sorting by file timestamps. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.0 | Search parameters: individual file/folder search/mark for recovery, file mask search/manual mark for recovery. File sorting by file extension, time, and size by clicking column names, buttons for most popular file types. Found files are appeared in a separate tab Search. Files can be shown in Large icons and Details. The program has two typed of filters: Filter (Lost Files, Recent Files, pictures, music, etc.) and Advanced Filter (files deleted and existing, file types, time stamps, size, the first letter, etc.). | |
Ontrack EasyRecovery | 5.0 | Search only for certain file types: all files, pictures, video, etc. Places to search in (Desktop, My Documents, Choose Location) may be explicitly specified. Individual file and file mask search. File sorting by file extension, time, and size by clicking column names. Files can be sorted by File Type, Tree View, Deleted List. Manual file mark for recovery. | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | Sorting by names, paths, sizes, dates, or deleted/existing. Special tabs for most common file types. Files can be sorted by clicking column names. Search for individual files and file masks. Files can be shown in List View, Tree View, and Tiles View (for pictures). Medium/Large tiles for graphic files. Files can be sorted by their chances for successful recovery. | |
Disk Drill for Windows | 5.0 | Manual marking for recovery, sorting by clicking column names and Ascending/Descanting. Search parameters: individual file search, file mask search, size search. Files can be filtered by their size (by selecting fixed sizes 0 KB, 128 KB, 512 KB, 1 MB, etc ,) by deleted within the last (any time, 1 day, 3 day, etc.), by file types: All files, Pictures, Video, etc. The Recover All button marks all files. There is an option Show hidden system files. | |
Recuva | 4.5 | Individual file and file mask search. Search for a specific path. Files can be shown in List View, Tree View, Thumbnails View. Files can be sorted by clicking column names or by using the Sorted by menu. Manual marking for recovery, with the Check all files, Check Highlighted, Uncheck Highlighted, Highlight Folder options. | |
Premium Recovery Software | 4.0 | Search parameters: individual file search, file mask search, size search, files can be sorted by clicking column names, manual mark for recovery. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.0 | Individual file and file mask search. Files can be sorted by clicking column names, manual mark for recovery. | |
All evaluated programs have quite advanced file search capabilities, which is essential when sifting through hundreds or thousands of recovered files. Restorer Ultimate has the best file search, sorting, and recovery mark options. EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard and R-Undelete have search capabilities most optimized for inexperienced users. Since our last review: R-Undelete can now sort files by their chances for successful recovery. Restorer Ultimate can sort and mark files by their chances for successful recovery. The program shows detailed information about a selected file. EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard can now search/mark folders by their names. Found files are appeared in a separate tab Search. The program has two typed of filters: Filter (Lost Files, Recent Files, pictures, music, etc.) and Advanced Filter (files deleted and existing, file types, time stamps, size, the first letter, etc.). Premium Recovery Software can now search files by their sizes. Ontrack EasyRecovery Professional has now manual mark for recovery, a place to search for files and 3 types of showing files are added. |
Deep analysis of disks (disk scan)
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Very versatile scan parameters. Disks can be scanned partially and combined with results of several different scans. Scan results may be stored in a file during the scan and loaded later. The user can control bad sector processing and memory usage. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.0 | A versatile scan parameter set. Disks can be scanned partially. Scan process can be paused and then resumed. Scan results are shown on separate tabs, like Drive – Deleted files, Lost Partition Files, Extra Files, etc. Scan results can be stored in a file after the scan is completed and may be loaded later. | |
Disk Drill for Windows | 5.0 | Scan types can be selected: Quick Scan, Deep Scan, Search for lost partitions, Allocate existing data, Undelete protected data, and All recovery methods. While scanning, the program starts showing the number and types for found files in the Pictures, Video, Audio, Documents, and Archives folders. Scan can be stopped and then resumed. Scan results are saved automatically or manually, can later be loaded, and be connected as a disk (the Show scan results in Explorer command). | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | Two separate scan modes: Deep Scan to find more lost files on existing logical disks, and Scan for partitions to find lost files on unrecognized and unallocated spaces on hard drives. No scan parameters can be specified. Scan results are automatically stored in a file and automatically loaded when another file recovery sessions starts with the same hard drive. Scan info files are automatically deleted in a certain amount of time. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.5 | Drive objects to scan and file types to search for can be specified. Scan results cannot be saved. | |
Recuva | 4.5 | Drive objects to scan and scan type (Quick Scan and Deep Scan) can be specified. Scan for non-deleted files can be performed for recovery from damaged or reformatted disks. | |
Premium Recovery Software | 4.5 | Drive objects to scan can be specified. Three scan types can be selected: Simple Scan, Advanced Scan, Smart Scan. Already found files can be shown during the scan process. Scan results are saved automatically. Scan can be stopped and then resumed. | |
Ontrack EasyRecovery | 4.5 | Two scan types can be selected: Scan and Deep Scan. Relatively few parameters can be specified. Places to scan (Desktop, My Documents, Choose Location, and other locations). Scan can be performed either for all file types, or for some specific ones: pictures, documents, etc. When the Turn On Preview option is enabled, picture files can be previewed immediately after recognition during scan process. Scan results can be saved and later loaded. | |
All tested programs support deep analysis of disks (disk scan), which is necessary to recover files from disks with damaged file systems. Most programs allow you to store and load scan results. Restorer Ultimate and EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard have the best set of scan parameters. R-Undelete has the most balanced scan process – it’s simple for inexperienced users yet provides all necessary options to recover files from both existing and lost logical disks. Disk Drill for Windows can connect scan results to Windows Explorer. Since our last review: EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard shows now scan results on separate tabs, like Drive – Deleted files, Lost Partition Files, Extra Files, etc. Premium Recovery Software has now the third scan type: Smart Scan. Ontrack EasyRecovery has a new scan procedure with new scan types. Scan info can be saved and loaded. |
Logging
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | Very versatile logging. The log can be saved to a file. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.5 | Versatile logging. The log can be saved to a file. | |
R-Undelete | 4.5 | Log shows which files were successfully recovered and which file recoveries failed. The log can be saved to a file. | |
Disk Drill for Windows | 4.5 | The log is automatically saved to the dd.log file. It can be viewed through the Disk Drill logs command. | |
Recuva | 4.0 | The list of recovered files can be saved using the Save List to Text File… command. | |
Premium Recovery Software | 4.0 | File recovery results can be viewed in the Recovered files list. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
Ontrack EasyRecovery | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
Most of the programs we evaluated had logging features. Restorer Ultimate, has very versatile logging features, which are equal to professional data recovery software. The rest of the programs with this feature merely show the list of successfully/unsuccessfully recovered files. Since our last review: Ontrack EasyRecovery Professional doesn`t have any log files. |
Disk imaging and copying
In cases where there is physical damage or mechanical failures on a hard drive, reading from the disk can cause further data loss. For this reason, creating an image of the disk before performing any file recovery tasks is a preferred best practice. This allows you to run multiple data recovery attempts on the image without causing further deterioration of the drive, in case you need to bring it to a professional data recovery company after a failed DIY attempt.
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Image types: byte-by-byte and compressed. Parameters specified: compression rate, file split size, password, bad sector processing. The program can scan disks and save scan info while imaging. | |
R-Undelete | 5.5 | Image types: compressed. No image parameters can be specified. The program can open other image file types like .dsk. The program can scan disks and save scan info while imaging. | |
Recuva | 4.5 | The program can create disk images in the vhd file format. Such files can be connected as virtual disks directly to Windows or to virtual machines. | |
Disk Drill for Windows | 4.0 | A drive backup can be created as a dmg file. It can be opened in the program to recover files from such images. The dmg file format is native to Mac computers and cannot be connected to Windows systems without third-party software. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
Ontrack EasyRecovery | 0.0 | No disk image support in the Home program version. Images can be created in the Demo, Professional, and Technical versions. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
Premium Recovery Software | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
Restorer Ultimate, R-Undelete, Recuva, and Disk Drill for Windows have disk imaging capabilities. Restorer Ultimate and R-Undelete also can scan the disks while creating their images. Disk Drill for Windows create images in the dmg file format native to Mac computers. Since our last review: R-Undelete can now scan disks while creating disk images. |
File recovery using file signatures (raw file recovery)
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Can be used alone on hard drives and partitions as an alternative file recovery method. Can be disabled, if necessary. User-selectable file types and support for custom file signatures, which can be added or edited using the built-in file signature editor. User file signatures can be stored in and loaded from a file. | |
Ontrack EasyRecovery | 5.0 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. The user can select which predefined file type is to be included and specify file size range. It can also attempt to concatenate broken video streams. The user can add custom-defined file types using a built-in editor. If necessary, this feature can be disabled. | |
Recuva | 4.5 | We could not find this feature, but it looks like the program has it: because it found raw files during tests. | |
Premium Recovery Software | 4.5 | We could not find this feature, but it looks like the program has it: quite often some files with modified names can be found in special folders after Advanced scan. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. | |
Disk Drill for Windows | 4.5 | We could not find this feature, but it looks like the program has it: some files with modified names can be found in the Found files, Reconstructed, and Found Labels sections. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. Found files are shown in a separate tab Extra Files. | |
R-Undelete | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. | |
All programs have this feature which is necessary when recovering files from severely damaged file systems. Two programs, Restorer Ultimate and Ontrack EasyRecovery Professional have built-in file signature editors that allow the user to add and edit custom-defined file types. Since our last review: EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard shows found raw files in a separate tab Extra Files. Ontrack EasyRecovery Professional have now a built-in file signature editor to add and edit custom-defined file types. |
File recovery using file signatures (raw file recovery)
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Can be used alone on hard drives and partitions as an alternative file recovery method. Can be disabled, if necessary. User-selectable file types and support for custom file signatures, which can be added or edited using the built-in file signature editor. User file signatures can be stored in and loaded from a file. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set (Extra Files). File types to search for cannot be selected. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. | |
Systweak Advanced Disk Recovery | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. | |
Seagate File Recovery | 4.5 | It looks like the program has this feature: quite often some files with modified names can be found in special folders after Advanced scan. | |
Wondershare Data Recovery | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. | |
R-Undelete | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. | |
Custom file signatures in Restorer Ultimate can be selected, added, and edited. |
File systems supported for file recovery
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 6.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, ReFS, Ext2/3, HFS+ | |
Raise Data Recovery | 6.0 | FAT/ExFAT, NTFS, HFS+, UFS, Ext2/Ext3/Ext4FS, ReiserFS, XFS, JFS, APFS | |
R-Undelete | 5.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, ReFS | |
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, ReFS, (Ext2/3/4 FS, USF1/UFS2, HFS/HFS+, and APFS in the Pro and Network version) | |
Seagate File Recovery | 4.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5 | |
Wondershare Data Recovery | 4.0 | FAT, NTFS/NTFS5 | |
Systweak Advanced Disk Recovery | 4.0 | FAT and NTFS/NTFS5 | |
All programs support standard Windows file systems: FAT and NTFS. Some support Mac and Linux file systems, which are required for recovering files from Mac computers and various NAS devices. Raise Data Recovery has the largest sets of supported file systems. Restorer Ultimate, EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard, and R-Undelete support the new Windows ReFS file system. If necessary, Restorer Ultimate can be upgraded to the PRO version which supports Mac OS (including APFS) and Linux file systems. Since our last review: Restorer Ultimate Pro supports the APFS file system. EaseUS supports now the ReFS file system. |
File search, mark for recovery, sorting
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | Search parameters: “Show only deleted files”, “Show only existing files”, individual file search/mark for recovery, file mask (including mask presets), search/mark for recovery, file search for date (separately for modification, creation, last access), file search for size, file search for file ID. Files can be sorted by clicking column names. Support for mass file recovery: file sorting by file extension, file sorting by file timestamps. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.0 | Search parameters: individual file search/mark for recovery, file mask search/manual mark for recovery. File sorting by file extension, time, size, and path by clicking column names, buttons for most popular file types. Files can be shown in Large icons, Details. The filter: All Files, Recent Files, Lost Files, Recycle Bin, file types. The Advanced Filter: Status (Deleted, Existing), file types, modification time, size, Initial Letter of File Name. | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | Sorting by names, paths, sizes, dates. Time mask and Deleted only masks. Special tabs for most common and custom file types. Files can be sorted by clicking column names. Search for individual files and file masks. Files can be shown in List View, Tree View, and Tiles View (for pictures). Medium/Large tiles for graphic files. | |
Seagate File Recovery | 5.0 | Individual file and file mask search. Sorting by file types and dates. Files can be sorted by clicking column names. Only selected files can be shown. Manual mark for recovery. | |
Wondershare Data Recovery | 4.5 | Individual file and file mask search. Search only for certain file types: all files, pictures, video, etc. A file data filter. File sorting by file extension, time, and size by clicking column names. Manual mark for recovery. | |
Systweak Advanced Disk Recovery | 4.5 | The “Show only deleted files”, “Show only existing files” options, file mask (File name wildcard). A file health filter: Unrecoverable, Good, Bad, Excellent, Poor, Existing. An attribute filter: System, ReadOnly, Compressed, Hidden, Encrypted. Time and size filters. File sorting by file extension, time, and size, location, attribute, State, Comment by clicking column names. Manual mark for recovery. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.0 | Individual file and file mask search. Files can be sorted by clicking column names, manual mark for recovery. | |
Most evaluated programs have quite advanced file search capabilities, which is essential when sifting through hundreds or thousands of recovered files. Restorer Ultimate has the best file search, sorting, and recovery mark options. Seagate Recovery Suite and R-Undelete have search capabilities most optimized for inexperienced users. Since our last review: EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard: new filtering features appeared. |
Logging
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | Very versatile logging. The log can be saved to a file. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.5 | Simple logging. The log can be saved to a file. | |
R-Undelete | 4.0 | Log shows which files were successfully recovered and which file recoveries failed. The log can be saved to a file. | |
Seagate File Recovery | 3.0 | Recovered file list. | |
Systweak Advanced Disk Recovery | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
Wondershare Data Recovery | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
About half of the programs we evaluated had logging features. Restorer Ultimate has very versatile logging features, which are equal to professional data recovery software. |
Disk imaging and copying
In cases where there is physical damage or mechanical failures on a hard drive, reading from the disk can cause further data loss. For this reason, creating an image of the disk before performing any file recovery tasks is the preferred practice. This allows you to run multiple data recovery attempts on the image without causing further deterioration of the drive, in case you need to bring it to a professional data recovery company after a failed DIY attempt.
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Image types: byte-by-byte and compressed. Parameters specified: compression rate, file split size, password, bad sector processing. The program can scan disks and save scan info while imaging. | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | Image types: compressed. No image parameters can be specified. The program can open other image file types like .dsk. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
Wondershare Data Recovery | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
Systweak Advanced Disk Recovery | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
Seagate File Recovery | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
Only Restorer Ultimate and R-Undelete have disk imaging capabilities. Restorer Ultimate also can scan the disks while creating their images. Since our last review: R-Undelete can now load several disk image file types. |
Deep analysis of disks (disk scan)
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Very versatile scan parameters. Disks can be scanned partially and combined with results of several different scans. Scan results may be stored in a file during the scan and loaded later. The user can control bad sector processing and memory usage. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.0 | Versatile scan parameter set. Disks can be scanned partially. Scan results can be stored in a file after the scan is completed and may be loaded later. | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | Two separate scan modes: Deep Scan to find more lost files on existing logical disks, and Scan for partitions to find lost files on unrecognized and unallocated spaces on hard drives. No scan parameters can be specified. Scan results are automatically stored in a file and automatically loaded when another file recovery sessions starts with the same hard drive. Scan info files are automatically deleted in a certain amount of time. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.5 | Drive objects to scan and file types to search for can be specified. Scan results cannot be saved. | |
Systweak Advanced Disk Recovery | 4.5 | Drive objects to scan and scan type (Quick Scan and Deep Scan) can be specified. The results of an interrupted scan can be loaded later and the scan process can be resumed. | |
Seagate File Recovery | 4.5 | Drive objects to scan can be specified. Already found files can be shown during the scan process. Scan results are saved automatically. Scan can be stopped then resumed. | |
Wondershare Data Recovery | 4.0 | Scan type can be specified: Formatted Disk Recovery, Lost Partition Recovery, etc. The program doesn’t show scan progress which is extremely inconvenient for large disks. Scan results cannot be saved. | |
All tested programs support deep analysis of disks (disk scan), which is necessary to recover files from disks with damaged file systems. Most programs allow you to store and load scan results. Restorer Ultimate and EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard have the best set of scan parameters. R-Undelete has the most balanced scan process – it’s simple for inexperienced users yet provides all necessary options to recover files from both existing and lost logical disks. |
File recovery parameters
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Recovers hidden attributes, system attributes, alternative data streams for NTFS, security attributes for NTFS. Files with the same names can be overwritten/renamed/skipped according to their time stamps, file sizes, etc. Bad sector processing can be specified. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.5 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Existing files can be overwritten, renamed, or skipped. | |
R-Undelete | 4.5 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Alternatively, it can recover files to their file types. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. | |
Systweak Advanced Disk Recovery | 4.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. | |
Seagate File Recovery | 4.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. | |
Wondershare Data Recovery | 4.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. | |
All programs can recover file names and the folder structure. Restorer Ultimate has the best file recovery parameter set and can recover various NTFS attributes. |
Disk parts/regions
Most programs require you to scan the entire disk. The ability to scan a specific region or disk part is normally an advanced feature for professional data recovery tools, but as hard drive capacities get larger and larger, this feature is extremely useful even for DIY data recovery. Limiting your scans to a specific disk part or region can greatly reduce your scan times when scanning larger disks.
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | Disk regions appear as objects that can be processed like regular disks. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No support for disk parts or regions. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 0.0 | No support for disk parts or regions. | |
Systweak Advanced Disk Recovery | 0.0 | No support for disk parts or regions. | |
Seagate File Recovery | 0.0 | No support for disk parts or regions. | |
Wondershare Data Recovery | 0.0 | No support for disk parts or regions. | |
R-Undelete | 0.0 | No support for disk parts or regions. | |
Only Restorer Ultimate has the region capabilities. |
S.M.A.R.T.
S.M.A.R.T., which stands for Self-Monitoring, Analysis and Reporting Technology, is a widely-used technology in hard drives and solid-state devices that monitors various reliability conditions and predicts possible hardware failures.
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
R-Undelete | 6.0 | S.M.A.R.T. attributes can be shown in a pop-up window. If bad S.M.A.R.T. data is present, the program shows a warning sign. | |
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Shows hard drive’s S.M.A.R.T. attributes in a pop-up window. When attempting to work with a drive with bad S.M.A.R.T. data, the program throws a special warning that recommends performing data recover from an image. | |
Seagate File Recovery | 5.5 | Two types of S.M.A.R.T. tests can be conducted, Short (Recommended) which is a fast S.M.A.R.T. test with most critical parameters, sampling the device and Extended – an extended version of the S.M.A.R.T. test that covers the entire device. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
Systweak Advanced Disk Recovery | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
Wondershare Data Recovery | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
Almost half of the tested programs, Restorer Ultimate, R-Undelete, and Seagate Recovery Suite have this feature. Restorer Ultimate not only shows the S.M.A.R.T. attributes, it also throws special warnings when the user tries to recover files from a drive with hardware issues. In a DIY program, this is particularly helpful since beginner users may not know the risk of attempting data recovery on a failing hard drive. |
Logging
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Active@ UNDELETE | 6.0 | Very versatile logging, including a forensic report. The log can be saved to a file. | |
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | Very versatile logging. The log can be saved to a file. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.5 | Versatile logging. The log can be saved to a file. | |
R-Undelete | 4.0 | Log shows which files were successfully recovered and which file recoveries failed. The log can be saved to a file. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
Recuva | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
Seagate Recovery Suite | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
About half of the programs we evaluated had logging features. Restorer Ultimate, Active@ UNDELETE 12 have very versatile logging features, which are equal to professional data recovery software. Active@ UNDELETE 12 even has a forensic report. Since our last review: R-Undelete can now save its log to a file. – Seagate Recovery Suite (when compared with Seagate File Recovery tested in 2016) lost its logging capability. |
S.M.A.R.T.
S.M.A.R.T., which stands for Self-Monitoring, Analysis and Reporting Technology, is a widely-used technology in hard drives and solid-state devices that monitors various reliability conditions and predicts possible hardware failures.
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
R-Undelete | 6.0 | S.M.A.R.T. attributes can be shown in a pop-up window. If bad S.M.A.R.T. data is present, the program shows a warning sign. | |
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Shows hard drive’s S.M.A.R.T. attributes in a pop-up window. When attempting to work with a drive with bad S.M.A.R.T. data, the program throws a special warning that recommends performing data recover from an image. | |
Seagate Recovery Suite | 5.5 | Two types of S.M.A.R.T. tests can be conducted, Short (Recommended) which is a fast S.M.A.R.T. test with most critical parameters, sampling the device and Extended – an extended version of the S.M.A.R.T. test that covers the entire device. | |
Active@ UNDELETE | 5.0 | S.M.A.R.T. attributes are shown in a special panel. No warning is displayed if bad S.M.A.R.T. data is present. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
Recuva | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
Only Restorer Ultimate, Active@ UNDELETE 12, R-Undelete, and Seagate Recovery Suite have this feature. Restorer Ultimate not only shows the S.M.A.R.T. attributes, it also throws special warnings when the user tries to recover files from a drive with hardware issues. In a DIY program, this is particularly helpful since beginner users may not know the risk of attempting data recovery on a failing hard drive. Since our last review: Seagate Recovery Suite now shows the S.M.A.R.T information. |
Disk imaging and copying
In cases where there is physical damage or mechanical failures on a hard drive, reading from the disk can cause further data loss. For this reason, creating an image of the disk before performing any file recovery tasks is a preferred best practice. This allows you to run multiple data recovery attempts on the image without causing further deterioration of the drive, in case you need to bring it to a professional data recovery company after a failed DIY attempt.
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Image types: byte-by-byte and compressed. Parameters specified: compression rate, file split size, password, bad sector processing. The program can scan disks and save scan info while imaging. | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | Image types: compressed. No image parameters can be specified. | |
Recuva | 4.5 | The program can create disk images in the vhd file format. Such files can be connected as virtual disks directly to Windows or to virtual machines. | |
Seagate Recovery Suite | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
Active@ UNDELETE | 0.0 | No disk image support in the standard program version. Images can be created in the demo version and professional version. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
Half of the programs, Restorer Ultimate, Recuva, and R-Undelete have disk imaging capabilities. Restorer Ultimate also can scan the disks while creating their images. Recuva creates images in the common vhd format which can be connected directly to Windows or used in virtual machines. Active@ UNDELETE 12 has disk imaging only in its demo and professional versions. Since our last review: R-Undelete can now create only compressed images without specifying its parameters. Seagate Recovery Suite (when compared with Seagate File Recovery tested in 2016) lost its ability to create disk images. |
Deep analysis of disks (disk scan)
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Very versatile scan parameters. Disks can be scanned partially and combined with results of several different scans. Scan results may be stored in a file during the scan and loaded later. The user can control bad sector processing and memory usage. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.0 | Versatile scan parameter set. Disks can be scanned partially. Scan results are can be stored in a file after the scan is completed and may be loaded later. | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | Two separate scan modes: Deep Scan to find more lost files on existing logical disks, and Scan for partitions to find lost files on unrecognized and unallocated spaces on hard drives. No scan parameters can be specified. Scan results are automatically stored in a file and automatically loaded when another file recovery sessions starts with the same hard drive. Scan info files are automatically deleted in a certain amount of time. | |
Active@ UNDELETE | 4.5 | Only one parameter can be specified: Ignore errors. Scan results can be saved, but only the Professional version can load them. The program can scan several objects simultaneously. | |
Seagate Recovery Suite | 4.5 | Drive objects to scan can be specified. Already found files can be shown during the scan process. Scan results are saved automatically. Scan can be stopped and them resumed. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.0 | Drive objects to scan and file types to search for can be specified. Scan results cannot be saved. | |
Recuva | 4.0 | Some scan parameters can be specified. Scan results cannot be saved. | |
All tested programs support deep analysis of disks (disk scan), which is necessary to recover files from disks with damaged file systems. Most programs allow you to store and load scan results. Restorer Ultimate and EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard have the best set of scan parameters. Active@ UNDELETE 12 can scan several objects simultaneously. R-Undelete has the most balanced scan process – it’s simple for inexperienced users yet provides all necessary options to recover files from both existing and lost logical disks. Since our last review: R-Undelete and Seagate Recovery Suite have now completely different scan interfaces. EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard has now a slightly different scan interface. |
Disk parts/regions
Most programs require you to scan the entire disk. The ability to scan a specific region or disk part is normally an advanced feature for professional data recovery tools, but as hard drive capacities get larger and larger, this feature is extremely useful even for DIY data recovery. Limiting your scans to a specific disk part or region can greatly reduce your scan times when scanning larger disks.
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | Disk regions appear as objects that can be processed like regular disks. | |
R-Undelete | 0.0 | No disk parts or region support. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No disk parts or region support. | |
Active@ UNDELETE | 0.0 | No disk parts or region support. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 0.0 | No disk parts or region support. | |
Recuva | 0.0 | No disk parts or region support. | |
Seagate Recovery Suite | 0.0 | No disk parts or region support. | |
Only Restorer Ultimate has the region capabilities. |
File search, mark for recovery, sorting
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | Search parameters: “Show only deleted files”, “Show only existing files”, individual file search/mark for recovery, file mask (including mask presets), search/mark for recovery, file search for date (separately for modification, creation, last access), file search for size, file search for file ID. Files can be sorted by clicking column names. Support for mass file recovery: file sorting by file extension, file sorting by file timestamps. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.0 | Search parameters: individual file search/mark for recovery, file mask search/manual mark for recovery. File sorting by file extension, time, and size by clicking column names, buttons for most popular file types. Files can be shown in Large icons, Details. | |
Active@ UNDELETE | 5.0 | Search parameters: “Show only deleted files”, “Show only existing files”, individual file search, file mask search, file search for date, file search for size, files can be sorted by clicking column names. Files from different sources can be saved in one place. | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | Sorting by names, paths, sizes, dates, or deleted/existing . Special tabs for most common file types. Files can be sorted by clicking column names. Search for individual files and file masks. Files can be shown in List View, Tree View, and Tiles View (for pictures). Medium/Large tiles for graphic files. | |
Seagate Recovery Suite | 5.0 | Individual file and file mask search. Sorting by file types and dates. Files can be sorted by clicking column names. Only Selected files can be shown. | |
Recuva | 4.5 | Individual file and file mask search. Search for a specific path. Files can be shown in List View, Tree View, Thumbnails View. Files can be sorted by clicking column names or by using the Sorted by menu. Manual marking for recovery, with the Check all files,Check Highlighted, Uncheck Highlighted, Highlight Folder options. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.0 | Individual file and file mask search. Files can be sorted by clicking column names, manual mark. | |
Most evaluated programs have quite advanced file search capabilities, which is essential when sifting through hundreds or thousands of recovered files. Active@ UNDELETE 12 and Restorer Ultimate have the best file search, sorting, and recovery mark options. Seagate Recovery Suite and R-Undelete have search capabilities most optimized for inexperienced users. Since our last review: R-Undelete and Seagate Recovery Suite have completely new file search interfaces. Restorer Ultimate can now set file mask presets. |
File recovery parameters
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Recovers hidden attributes, system attributes, alternative data streams for NTFS, security attributes for NTFS. Files with the same names can be overwritten/renamed/skipped according to their time stamps, file sizes, etc. Bad sector processing can be specified. | |
Active@ UNDELETE | 5.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Recovered files can be renamed, and existing files can be specially processed. Some other recovery parameters can be used: Create original folder (group) structure, Recover Named Streams, Use Disk Lock, Ignore Disk Lock Errors, Ignore Write Errors, Ignore Read Errors Bad sector processing can be specified. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.5 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Existing files can be overwritten, renamed, or skipped. | |
R-Undelete | 4.5 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Alternatively, it can recover files to their file types. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. | |
Recuva | 4.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. The file list can be saved to a text file. | |
Seagate Recovery Suite | 4.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. | |
All programs can recover file names and the folder structure. Restorer Ultimate and Active@ UNDELETE 12 have the best file recovery parameter set and can recover various NTFS attributes. Since our last review: Seagate Recovery Suite (when compared with Seagate File Recovery tested in 2016) and R-Undelete can now recover only file names and the folder structure. Restorer Ultimate can now process duplicate files according to their sizes and time stamps. |
File recovery using file signatures (raw file recovery)
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Can be used alone on hard drives and partitions as an alternative file recovery method. Can be disabled, if necessary. User-selectable file types and support for custom file signatures, which can be added or edited using the built-in file signature editor. User file signatures can be stored in and loaded from a file. | |
R-Undelete | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. | |
Seagate Recovery Suite | 4.0 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.0 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.0 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. File types to search for cannot be selected. | |
Recuva | 0.0 | We could not find support for raw file recovery. | |
Active@ UNDELETE | 0.0 | We could not find support for raw file recovery feature in the standard version; only available in Ultimate, Professional, and Demo. | |
Half of the tested programs don’t have this feature which is necessary when the file system on the disk is severely damaged: Active@ UNDELETE 12, and Recuva. Note that Active@ UNDELETE 12 has this feature in its demo mode, but you must purchase the professional version to recover more than one file up to 1 MB in size. Custom file signatures in Restorer Ultimate can be selected, added, and edited. Since our last review: In R-Undelete and Raise Data Recovery, the users cannot now select which file types should be searched for. |
File systems supported for file recovery
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 6.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, ReFS, Ext2/3, HFS+ | |
Active@ UNDELETE | 6.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS, NTFS(EFS), ReFS, HFS+, Ext2/Ext3/Ext4, UFS, BtrFS, JFS | |
Raise Data Recovery | 6.0 | FAT/ExFAT, NTFS, HFS+, UFS, Ext2/Ext3/Ext4FS, ReiserFS, XFS, JFS, APFS | |
R-Undelete | 5.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, ReFS | |
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, ReFS | |
Seagate Recovery Suite | 4.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5 | |
Recuva | 4.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5 | |
All programs support standard Windows file systems: FAT and NTFS. Some support Mac and Linux file systems, which are required for recovering files from Mac computers and various NAS devices. Raise Data Recovery and Active@ UNDELETE 12 have the largest sets of supported file systems, the first one even supports the newest Apple file system – APFS. This is even a rare feature among Mac file recovery programs. Active@ UNDELETE 12, Restorer Ultimate, EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard, and R-Undelete support the new Windows ReFS file system. If necessary, Restorer Ultimate can be upgraded to the PRO version which supports Mac OS and Linux file systems. Since our last review: Raise Data Recovery supports now the newest Apple file system APFS. Active@ UNDELETE 12 supports now the ReFS and JFS file systems. EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard supports now the ReFS file system. |
File search, mark for recovery, sorting
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
R-Undelete | 5.5 | Search parameters: “Show only deleted files”, “Show only existing files”, individual file search/mark for recovery, file mask search/mark for recovery, file search for date (separately for modification, creation, last access), file search for size, file search for file ID. Support for mass file recovery: file sorting by file extension, file sorting by file timestamps. | |
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | Search parameters: “Show only deleted files”, “Show only existing files”, individual file search/mark for recovery, file mask search/mark for recovery, file search for date (separately for modification, creation, last access)*, file search for size, file search for file ID. Support for mass file recovery: file sorting by file extension, file sorting by file timestamps. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.0 | Search parameters: individual file search/mark for recovery, file mask search/manual mark for recovery, file sorting by file extension, time, and size, buttons for most popular file types*. | |
Active@ UNDELETE | 5.0 | Search parameters: “Show only deleted files”, “Show only existing files”, individual file search, file mask search, file search for date, file search for size, files can be sorted by clicking column names. Files from different sources can be saved in one place. There is also a separate option Organize by dates, extensions, and applications.Files can be filtered out (Filtered by). There is a file organizer in the program. | |
Kernel for Windows Data Recovery | 4.5 | Search parameters: file patterns, File filer, Files can be sorted by clicking column names. | |
Auslogics File Recovery | 4.5 | Search parameters: individual file search, file mask search, file search for date, file sorting by mask and type. Files can be sorted by clicking column names. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.0 | Search parameters: individual file search, files can be sorted by clicking column names. | |
Ontrack® EasyRecovery™ Home | 4.0 | Search parameters: individual file search, file mask search, files can be sorted by clicking column names. | |
Most evaluated programs have quite advanced file search capabilities, which is essential when sifting through hundreds or thousands of recovered files. Active@ UNDELETE, Restorer Ultimate, and R-Undelete have the best file search, sorting, and recovery mark options. *Since our last review: R-Undelete and Restorer Ultimate can now set time stamps in file search separately for modification, creation, and last access. EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard now has special buttons to show the most popular file types. |
File systems supported for file recovery
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Raise Data Recovery | 6.0 | FAT/ExFAT, NTFS, HFS+, UFS, Ext2/Ext3/Ext4FS, ReiserFS, XFS, JFS | |
Active@ UNDELETE | 6.0 | FAT, NTFS, NTFS(EFS), HFS+, Ext2/Ext3/Ext4, UFS, BtrFS | |
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, ReFS | |
R-Undelete | 5.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, ReFS | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, Ext2/3, HFS+ | |
Ontrack® EasyRecovery™ Home | 5.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, HFS+ for external devices | |
Kernel for Windows Data Recovery | 4.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5 | |
Auslogics File Recovery | 3.0 | FAT/NTFS | |
The standard Windows file systems FAT/exFAT and NTFS are generally enough for Windows DIY file recovery software, and all tested programs support them. Restorer Ultimate and R-Undelete support the new Windows ReFS file system. Some programs support Mac and Linux file systems, which are required for recovering files from Mac computers and various NAS devices. We gave some extra points to Raise Data Recovery and Active@ UNDELETE for having the largest sets of supported file systems, although those file systems are not common among home and small business computers. |
File recovery parameters
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Recovers hidden attributes, system attributes, alternative data streams for NTFS, security attributes for NTFS. Raw files (files found using file signatures) can be enabled or disable during the data recovery. Files with the same names can be renamed during recovery. Bad sector processing can be specified. | |
R-Undelete | 5.5 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Recovers hidden attributes, system attributes, alternative data streams for NTFS, security attributes for NTFS. Files with the same names can be renamed during recovery. Raw files (files found using file signatures) can be enabled or disabled during the data recovery. Bad sector processing can be specified. | |
Active@ UNDELETE | 4.5 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Recovered files can be renamed. Some other recovery parameters can be used: Recover Named Streams, Use Disk Lock, Ignore Disk Lock Errors, Ignore Write Errors, Ignore Read Errors. | |
Kernel for Windows Data Recovery | 4.5 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Existing files can be overwritten, renamed, or skipped. Bad sector processing can be specified. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.5 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Existing files can be overwritten, renamed, or skipped. | |
Ontrack® EasyRecovery™ Home | 4.5 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Existing files can be overwritten, renamed, or skipped. Empty folders can be automatically removed. Bad sector processing can be specified. | |
Auslogics File Recovery | 4.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. | |
All programs can recover file names and the folder structure. Restorer Ultimate, R-Undelete, and Active@ UNDELETE have the best file recovery parameter set and can recover various NTFS attributes. |
Disk parts/regions
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | Disk regions appear as objects that can be processed like regular disks. | |
Ontrack® EasyRecovery™ Home | 3.0 | A disk area of a file system can be specified. | |
Active@ UNDELETE | 1.0 | No disk parts or region support. Images can be created in the demo, professional, and ultimate versions | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No disk parts or region support. | |
Auslogics File Recovery | 0.0 | No disk parts or region support. | |
R-Undelete | 0.0 | No disk parts or region support. | |
Kernel for Windows Data Recovery | 0.0 | No disk parts or region support. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 0.0 | No disk parts or region support. | |
Disk parts or regions is a very useful feature: limiting your scans to a specific disk part or region can greatly reduce your scan times when scanning larger disks. At the same time, this feature requires an advanced knowledge of data storage on hard drives and may confuse an inexperienced user. That is why we typically consider this is a feature for professional rather than DIY software. Still, two programs have it: Restorer Ultimate can work with full-fledged regions, and in Ontrack EasyRecovery Home, a disk area can be specified for a certain file system. |
File recovery using file signatures (raw file recovery)
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Can be used alone on hard drives and partitions as an alternative file recovery method. Can be disabled, if necessary. User-selectable file types and support for custom file signatures, which can be added or edited using the built-in file signature editor. User file signatures can be stored in and loaded from a file. | |
Ontrack® EasyRecovery™ Home | 5.0 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. The user can select which predefined file type is to be included and specify file size range. It can also attempt to concatenate broken video streams. If necessary, this feature can be disabled. | |
R-Undelete | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. You can select which predefined file types to include in the search. | |
Kernel for Windows Data Recovery | 4.5 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. The user can select which predefined file type is to be included and specify file size. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.0 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 4.0 | Supports raw file recovery with a pre-defined file signature set. If necessary, it can be disabled. | |
Active@ UNDELETE | 0.0 | No support for raw file recovery feature in the standard version; only available in Ultimate, Professional, and Demo. | |
Auslogics File Recovery | 0.0 | No support for raw file recovery. | |
All tested programs, except Auslogics File Recovery and Active@ UNDELETE, have this feature which is necessary when the file system on the disk is severely damaged. Note that Active@ UNDELETE has this feature in its demo mode, but you must purchase the professional version to recover more than one file up to 1 MB in size. Several programs allow users to select which file types are to be included in the raw file search. You can add and edit custom file signatures in Restorer Ultimate. |
Disk imaging and copying
In cases where there is physical damage or mechanical failures on a hard drive, reading from the disk can cause further data loss. For this reason, creating an image of the disk before performing any file recovery tasks is a preferred best practice. This allows you to run multiple data recovery attempts on the image without causing further deterioration of the drive, in case you need to bring it to a professional data recovery company after a failed DIY attempt.
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
R-Undelete | 6.0 | The program can create two types of images: byte-by-byte and compressed. Several image parameters can be specified: compression rate, file split size, password, and bad sector processing. The program can scan disks and save scan info while imaging. | |
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Image types: byte-by-byte and compressed. Parameters specified: compression rate, file split size, password, bad sector processing. The program can scan disks and save scan info while imaging. | |
Auslogics File Recovery | 4.0 | The program can create and load disk images. | |
Active@ UNDELETE | 2.0 | No disk image support in the standard program version. Images can be created in the demo, professional, and ultimate versions. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
Kernel for Windows Data Recovery | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
Ontrack® EasyRecovery™ Home | 0.0 | No disk image support in the Home version of the program. The Professional version includes a disk imaging tool. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No disk image support. | |
Restorer Ultimate, R-Undelete, and Auslogics File Recovery have the best disk imaging capabilities. Restorer Ultimate and R-Undelete can also scan the disks while creating their images. At the same time, complex image parameters in Restorer Ultimate and R-Undelete may confuse an inexperienced user. Active@ UNDELETE has disk imaging only in its demo, professional, and ultimate versions. |
Logging
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Active@ UNDELETE | 6.0 | Very versatile logging, including a forensic report. The log can be saved to a file. | |
Ontrack® EasyRecovery™ Home | 5.5 | Very versatile logging. The log can be saved to a file. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 5.5 | Very versatile logging. The log can be saved to a file. | |
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | Very versatile logging. The log can be saved to a file. | |
R-Undelete | 3.0 | Log shows which files were successfully recovered and which file recoveries failed. | |
Auslogics File Recovery | 3.0 | Logs a list of successfully recovered / failed to recover files | |
Kernel for Windows Data Recovery | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No logging capabilities. | |
About half of the programs we evaluated had logging features. Restorer Ultimate, Active@ UNDELETE, Ontrack EasyRecovery Home, and Raise Data Recovery have very versatile logging features, which are equal to professional data recovery software. Active@ UNDELETE even has a forensic report. |
Deep analysis of disks (disk scan)
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Very versatile scan parameters. Search only for specified file systems during the scan. Disks can be scanned partially and combined with results of several different scans. Scan results may be stored in a file during the scan and loaded later. The user can control bad sector processing and memory usage. | |
Ontrack® EasyRecovery™ Home | 5.0 | Some scan parameters (file system, scan area, etc.) can be specified. Scan results may be stored in a log file, no scan information can be stored. The user can control bad sector processing. | |
Auslogics File Recovery | 5.0 | Some scan parameters can be specified. Scan results cannot be saved. The program can scan several objects simultaneously. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.0 | Versatile scan parameter set. Disks can be scanned partially. Scan results are automatically stored in a file after the scan is completed and may be loaded later. | |
Active@ UNDELETE | 4.5 | Only one parameter can be specified: Ignore errors. Scan results can be saved. Scan can be performed for specific files and in specific areas. The program can scan several objects simultaneously. | |
Kernel for Windows Data Recovery | 4.5 | Some scan parameters (file system, scan area, etc.) can be specified. Scan results may be stored in a file during the scan and loaded later. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 3.5 | Some scan parameters can be specified. Scan results cannot be saved. | |
R-Undelete | 3.5 | No scan parameters can be specified. Scan results may be stored in a file during the scan and loaded later. | |
All tested programs support deep analysis of disks (disk scan), which is necessary to recover files from disks with damaged file systems. Most programs allow you to store and load scan results. Restorer Ultimate and EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard have the best sets of scan parameters, although they may confuse an inexperienced user for whom the default values may be optimal. Active@ UNDELETE and Auslogics File Recovery can scan several objects simultaneously. |
S.M.A.R.T.
S.M.A.R.T., which stands for Self-Monitoring, Analysis and Reporting Technology, is a widely-used technology in hard drives and solid-state devices that monitors various reliability conditions and predicts possible hardware failures.
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Shows hard drive’s S.M.A.R.T. attributes in a pop-up window. When attempting to work with a drive with bad S.M.A.R.T. data, the program throws a special warning that recommends performing data recover from an image. | |
R-Undelete | 6.0 | S.M.A.R.T. attributes shown in a pop-up window. If bad S.M.A.R.T. data is present, displays a warning message with a recommendation to image the drive and work from the image. | |
Active@ UNDELETE | 5.0 | S.M.A.R.T. attributes are shown in a special panel. No warning is displayed if bad S.M.A.R.T. data is present. | |
Ontrack® EasyRecovery™ Home | 4.5 | S.M.A.R.T. attributes are shown in a special panel accessible deep within the Disk Diagnostics part. No warning is displayed if bad S.M.A.R.T. data is present. | |
Raise Data Recovery | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
Auslogics File Recovery | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
Kernel for Windows Data Recovery | 0.0 | No S.M.A.R.T. capabilities. | |
Only Restorer Ultimate, Active@ UNDELETE, R-Undelete, and Ontrack EasyRecovery Home have this feature. Restorer Ultimate and R-Undelete not only show the S.M.A.R.T. attributes, they also throw special warnings when the user tries to recover files from a drive with hardware issues. In a DIY program, this is particularly helpful since beginner users may not know the risk of attempting data recovery on a failing hard drive. |
File search, mark for recovery, sorting
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | Search parameters: “Show only deleted files”, “Show only existing files”, individual file search/mark for recovery, file mask search/mark for recovery, file search for date, file search for size, file search for file ID. Support for mass file recovery: file sorting by file extension, file sorting by file timestamps. | |
R-Undelete | 5.5 | Search parameters: “Show only deleted files”, “Show only existing files”, individual file search/mark for recovery, file mask search/mark for recovery, file search for date, file search for size, file search for file ID. Support for mass file recovery: file sorting by file extension, file sorting by file timestamps. | |
Seagate File Recovery | 5.5 | Search parameters: “Show only deleted files”, “Show only existing files”, individual file search/mark for recovery, file mask search/mark for recovery, file search for date, file search for size, file search for file ID. Support for mass file recovery: file sorting by file extension and timestamps. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.0 | Search parameters: individual file search/mark for recovery, file mask search/manual mark for recovery, file sorting by file extension, time, and size. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 4.0 | Search parameters: individual file search, file mask search, file sorting by file extension. | |
Data Rescue PC3 | 4.0 | Search parameters: individual file search, file mask search, file search for date, file sorting by mask and status. | |
Undelete360 | 3.5 | Search parameters: file mask search, file search for date, file search for size. | |
Systweak Advanced Disk Recovery | 3.5 | Search parameters: “Show only deleted files”, “Show only existing files”, file mask: health: Unrecoverable, Good, Bad, Excellent, Poor, Existing. File sorting by file extension and size. An attribute filter: System, ReadOnly, Compressed, Hidden, Encrypted. | |
Most evaluated programs have quite advanced file search capabilities. Seagate File Recovery, Restorer Ultimate, and R-Undelete have the best file search, sorting, and recovery mark options. |
Disk imaging and copying
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Data Rescue PC3 | 6.0 | Image types: byte-by-byte. There’s a special clone module that allows the user to copy any file, partition, or disk to another file, partition, or disk. | |
Seagate File Recovery | 5.5 | Image types: byte-by-byte and compressed. Parameters specified: compression rate, file split size, password, bad sector processing. The program can scan disks while imaging. | |
R-Undelete | 5.5 | Image types: byte-by-byte and compressed. Parameters specified: compression rate, file split size, password, bad sector processing. The program can scan disks while imaging. | |
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | Image types: byte-by-byte and compressed. Parameters specified: compression rate, file split size, password, bad sector processing. The program can scan disks while imaging. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
Undelete360 | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
Systweak Advanced Disk Recovery | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program | |
Disk imaging is a very useful feature when working with disks with potential hardware problems. If a hard drive is failing, the best practice is to create an image of the disk first, and then perform all file recovery tasks from the image. Disk imaging is also helpful if you want to keep the data intact to bring to a data recovery professional, if your DIY attempts are not successful. Restorer Ultimate and R-Undelete have the best disk imaging capabilities. They also can scan the disks while creating their images. Data Rescue PC3 can copy any file, partition, or disk to another file, partition, or disk. Since our last review: The disk imaging feature disappeared in EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard. |
S.M.A.R.T.
S.M.A.R.T., which stands for Self-Monitoring, Analysis and Reporting Technology, is a widely-used technology in hard drives and solid-state devices that monitors various reliability conditions and predicts possible hardware failures.
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Shows hard drive’s S.M.A.R.T. attributes in a pop-up window. When attempting to work with a drive with bad S.M.A.R.T. data, the program throws a special warning that recommends performing data recovery from an image. | |
R-Undelete | 6.0 | S.M.A.R.T. attributes shown in a pop-up window. If bad S.M.A.R.T. data is present, displays a warning message with a recommendation to image the drive and work from the image. | |
Seagate File Recovery | 6.0 | S.M.A.R.T. attributes shown in a pop-up window. If bad S.M.A.R.T. data is present, displays a warning message with a recommendation to image the drive and work from the image. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
Data Rescue PC3 | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
Undelete360 | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
Systweak Advanced Disk Recovery | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
Only Restorer Ultimate, Seagate File Recovery, and R-Undelete have this feature. They not only show the S.M.A.R.T. attributes, they also throw special warnings when the user tries to recover files from a drive with hardware issues. |
File recovery using file signatures (raw file recovery)
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Can be used alone on hard drives and partitions as an alternative file recovery method. Can be disabled, if necessary. The user can specify which file type to search for. The program also supports custom file signatures, which can be added or edited using the built-in file signature editor. User file signatures can be stored in and loaded from a file | |
R-Undelete | 4.5 | This feature exists with a pre-defined file signature set. The user can select which predefined file type is to be included. | |
Seagate File Recovery | 4.5 | This feature exists with a pre-defined file signature set. The user can select which predefined file type is to be included. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.0 | This feature exists with a pre-defined file signature set. | |
Systweak Advanced Disk Recovery | 4.0 | This feature exists with a pre-defined file signature set. | |
Data Rescue PC3 | 4.0 | This feature exists with a pre-defined file signature set. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 4.0 | This feature exists with a pre-defined file signature set. Can be disabled, if necessary. | |
Undelete360 | 0.0 | No such feature. | |
All tested programs, except Undelete360, have this feature which is necessary when the file system on the disk is severely damaged. Several programs allow users to select which file types are to be included in the raw file search. The user can add and edit custom file signatures in Restorer Ultimate. |
Logging
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | Very versatile logging. The log can be saved to a file. | |
Undelete360 | 4.0 | A special Software Log tab. | |
R-Undelete | 3.0 | Logs a list of successfully recovered / failed to recover files. | |
Seagate File Recovery | 3.0 | Logs a list of successfully recovered / failed to recover files. | |
Data Rescue PC3 | 2.0 | Can save some debug information. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
Systweak Advanced Disk Recovery | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
About half of the programs we evaluated had logging features. Restorer Ultimate has the best logging features, which are equal to professional data recovery software. |
File systems supported for file recovery
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 6.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, Ext2/3, HFS+ | |
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, ReFS Can be upgraded to the PRO version, which supports HFS/HFS+, Ext2/3/4fs, and UFS file systems. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 5.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, search for HFS+ and CD/DVD | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, ReFS. | |
Seagate File Recovery | 5.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, ReFS | |
Undelete360 | 3.0 | FAT/NTFS | |
Systweak Advanced Disk Recovery | 3.0 | FAT/NTFS | |
Data Rescue PC3 | 3.0 | FAT/NTFS | |
All programs support standard Windows file systems: FAT and NTFS. Some support Mac and Linux file systems, which are required for recovering files from Mac computers and various NAS devices. EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard has the largest set of supported file systems. Restorer Ultimate, Seagate File Recovery, and R-Undelete support the new ReFS file system. If necessary, Restorer Ultimate can be upgraded to the PRO version which supports Mac OS and Linux file systems. Since our last review: EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard supports two additional file system: exFAT and HFS+. |
Disk parts/regions
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | Disk regions appear as objects that can be processed like regular disks. | |
Data Rescue PC3 | 4.0 | Separate disk areas can be scanned. | |
Seagate File Recovery | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
Undelete360 | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
Systweak Advanced Disk Recovery | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
R-Undelete | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
Regions or disk parts are useful when it’s necessary to process only a part of disk, for example, only the disk area where a deleted partition might reside. Disk parts/regions support can save a significant amount of time when scanning very large disks. Although this is more of a feature for professional software, the top-rated DIY programs should have it. Restorer Ultimate has the best region capabilities. Some of the other evaluated programs have a disk area either for imaging or scanning. Since our last review: The region capabilities disappeared in EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard. |
Deep analysis of disks (disk scan)
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Very versatile scan parameters. Disks can be scanned partially and combined with results of several different scans. Scan results may be stored in a file during the scan and loaded later. The user can control bad sector processing and memory usage. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.0 | Versatile scan parameter set. Disks can be scanned partially. Scan results are automatically stored in a file after the scan is completed and may be loaded later. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 4.0 | Some scan parameters (file systems to search for, type of disk objects, etc ) can be specified. Scan results are automatically stored in a file after the scan is completed and may be loaded later. Scan results cannot be loaded in the demo version. | |
Data Rescue PC3 | 3.5 | Some scan parameters (file systems to search for, type of disk objects, scan area, etc.) can be specified. Scan results may be stored in a file during the scan and loaded later. | |
Seagate File Recovery | 2.5 | No scan parameters can be specified. Scan results may be stored in a file during the scan and loaded later. | |
R-Undelete | 2.5 | No scan parameters can be specified. Scan results may be stored in a file during the scan and loaded later. | |
Systweak Advanced Disk Recovery | 2.5 | No scan parameters can be specified. The results of an interrupted scan can be loaded later and the scan can be resumed. | |
Undelete360 | 0.0 | No deep analysis of disks (disk scan) in this program. | |
All tested programs, except Undelete360, have this feature which is necessary to recover files from disks with damaged file systems. Most programs allow their users to store and load scan results. Restorer Ultimate and EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard have the best set of scan parameters. Since our last review: MiniTool Power Data Recovery increased the number of scan parameters that can be specified. |
File recovery parameters
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Recovers hidden attributes, system attributes, alternative data streams for NTFS, security attributes for NTFS. Raw files (files found using file signatures) can be included to / excluded from, the data recovery. Files with the same names can be renamed during recovery. Bad sector processing can be specified. | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Recovers hidden attributes, system attributes, alternative data streams for NTFS, security attributes for NTFS. Files with the same names can be renamed during recovery. Raw files (files found using file signatures) can be included to / excluded from, the data recovery. Bad sector processing can be specified. | |
Seagate File Recovery | 5.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Recovers hidden attributes, system attributes, alternative data streams for NTFS, security attributes for NTFS. Files with the same names can be renamed during recovery. Raw files (files found using file signatures) can be included to / excluded from, the data recovery. Bad sector processing can be specified. | |
Undelete360 | 4.5 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Recovers system attributes, alternative data streams for NTFS, time stamps for NTFS. | |
Systweak Advanced Disk Recovery | 4.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 4.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. | |
Data Rescue PC3 | 4.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. | |
All programs can recover file names and the folder structure. Restorer Ultimate, Seagate File Recovery, and R-Undelete have the best file recovery parameter set and can recover various NTFS attributes. |
File search, mark for recovery, sorting
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | Search parameters: “Show only deleted files”, “Show only existing files”, individual file search/mark for recovery, file mask search/mark for recovery, file search for date, file search for size, file search for file ID. Support for mass file recovery: file sorting by file extension, file sorting by file timestamps. | |
Handy Recovery | 5.5 | Search parameters: “Show only deleted files”, “Show only existing files”, individual file search/mark for recovery, file mask search/mark for recovery, file search for date, file search for size, file sorting by file extension, file sorting by file time. | |
R-Undelete | 5.5 | Search parameters: “Show only deleted files”, “Show only existing files”, individual file search/mark for recovery, file mask search/mark for recovery, file search for date, file search for size, file search for file ID. Support for mass file recovery: file sorting by file extension, file sorting by file timestamps. | |
Active@ File Recovery Ultimate Corporate | 5.5 | Search parameters: “Show only deleted files”, “Show only existing files”, individual file search/mark for recovery, file mask search, file search for date, file search for size, file search for file ID. | |
Recover My Files | 5.0 | Search parameters: “Show only deleted files”, individual file search/mark for recovery, file mask search/mark for recovery, file search for date, file search for size. Files can be sorted by extension and date. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.0 | Search parameters: individual file search/mark for recovery, file mask search/mark for recovery, file search for date, file search for size, file sorting by file extension. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 4.0 | Search parameters: individual file search, file mask search, file search for date, file search for size | |
Stellar Phoenix Windows Data Recovery Home | 3.5 | Search parameters: “Show only deleted files”, “Show only existing files”, individual file search, file sorting by file extension, file sorting by file time. | |
Orion File Recovery | 2.5 | Only individual file search is present; file sorting can be done by clicking the column headers in the list. | |
Ontrack® EasyRecovery™ Enterprise | 2.0 | Only individual file search is present; no support for file sorting. | |
Most evaluated programs have quite advanced file search capabilities. Handy Recovery, Restorer Ultimate, Active@File Recovery, and R-Undelete have the best file search, sorting, and recovery mark options. |
File systems supported for file recovery
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Handy Recovery | 5.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, HFS/HFS+, EFS | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 5.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, search for HFS+ and CD/DVD | |
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, ReFS Can be upgraded to the PRO version, which supports HFS/HFS+, Ext2/3/4fs, and UFS file systems. | |
Ontrack® EasyRecovery™ Enterprise | 5.5 | FAT, NTFS/NTFS 5, HFS/HFS+, Ext2/Ext3, ISO9660 | |
Active@ File Recovery Ultimate Corporate | 5.5 | NTFS, NTFS+EFS, exFAT, FAT/FAT32, HFS+, UFS and Ext2/Ext3/Ext4fs | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.0 | FAT, NTFS/NTFS5, Ext2/3 | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, ReFS. | |
Stellar Phoenix Windows Data Recovery Home | 5.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5 | |
Recover My Files | 4.0 | NTFS, FAT, exFAT, HFS, HFS+ | |
Orion File Recovery | 3.5 | FAT and NTFS | |
All programs support standard Windows file systems: FAT and NTFS. Some support Mac and Linux file systems, which are required for recovering files from Mac computers and various NAS devices. Ontrack® EasyRecovery™ Home and Active@File Recovery have the largest sets of supported file systems. Restorer Ultimate and R-Undelete support the new ReFS file system. If necessary, Restorer Ultimate can be upgraded to the PRO version which supports Mac OS and Linux file systems. |
Disk imaging and copying
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | Image types: byte-by-byte and compressed. Parameters specified: compression rate, file split size, password, bad sector processing. The program can scan disks while imaging. | |
R-Undelete | 5.5 | Image types: byte-by-byte and compressed. Parameters specified: compression rate, file split size, password, bad sector processing. The program can scan disks and save scan info while imaging. | |
Recover My Files | 5.5 | Image types: byte-by-byte and compressed. Parameters specified: Image area and compression ratio. | |
Active@ File Recovery Ultimate Corporate | 5.5 | Image types: byte-by-byte and compressed. Parameters specified: Image compression ratio, file split size, and bad sector processing. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.0 | Image types: byte-by-byte and compressed. Parameters specified: compression rate, file split size, bad sector processing. | |
Handy Recovery | 5.0 | Image types: byte-by-byte and compressed. Parameters specified: compression rate, file split size. | |
Ontrack® EasyRecovery™ Enterprise | 4.0 | Only an image created by the software is supported. No support for a common byte to byte image that is usually supported by other data recovery programs. An image can be restored to another disk. Disk objects can also be copied. | |
Stellar Phoenix Windows Data Recovery Home | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
Orion File Recovery | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
Disk imaging is a very useful feature when working with disks with potential hardware problems. If a hard drive is failing, the best practice is to create an image of the disk first, and then perform all file recovery tasks from the image. Disk imaging is also helpful if you want to keep the data intact to bring to a data recovery professional, if your DIY attempts are not successful. Restorer Ultimate and R-Undelete have the best disk imaging capabilities. They also can scan the disks while creating their images. Ontrack® EasyRecovery™ Home can restore images and copy disk objects. |
Disk parts/regions
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | Disk regions appear as objects that can be processed like regular disks. | |
Ontrack® EasyRecovery™ Enterprise | 5.0 | A region in per cents can be specified for all disk objects; bad block ranges can be created, saved, and loaded. | |
Recover My Files | 4.0 | An area to scan can be specified. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.0 | Separate disk areas can be imaged. | |
Handy Recovery | 4.0 | Separate disk areas can be imaged. | |
Active@ File Recovery Ultimate Corporate | 4.0 | An area to scan can be specified. | |
Orion File Recovery | 1.5 | Specific folders can be scanned, such as the Recycle Bin. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
R-Undelete | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
Stellar Phoenix Windows Data Recovery Home | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
Regions or disk parts are useful when it’s necessary to process only a part of disk, for example, only the disk area where a deleted partition might reside. Disk parts/regions support can save a significant amount of time when scanning very large disks. Although this is more of a feature for professional software, most of the top-rated DIY programs have it. Restorer Ultimate and Ontrack® EasyRecovery™ Home have the best region capabilities. Most of the other evaluated programs have a disk area either for imaging or scanning. |
File recovery parameters
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Recovers hidden attributes, system attributes, alternative data streams for NTFS, security attributes for NTFS. Extra Found Files (files found using file signatures) can be included to / excluded from, the data recovery. Files with the same names can be renamed during recovery. Bad sector processing can be specified. | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Recovers hidden attributes, system attributes, alternative data streams for NTFS, security attributes for NTFS. Files with the same names can be renamed during recovery. | |
Ontrack® EasyRecovery™ Enterprise | 4.5 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Files with the same names can be renamed during recovery. | |
Active@ File Recovery Ultimate Corporate | 4.5 | Recovers file names, the folder structure, and named streams. Files with the same names can be renamed during recovery. | |
Recover My Files | 4.0 | Recovers file names and the folder structure. Recovery of empty folders and zero-sized and deleted files can be disabled. | |
Stellar Phoenix Windows Data Recovery Home | 4.0 | Recovers file names and folder structure. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.0 | Recovers file names and folder structure. | |
Handy Recovery | 4.0 | Recovers file names and folder structure. Recovers alternative data streams for NTFS. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 4.0 | Recovers file names and folder structure. | |
Orion File Recovery | 3.5 | Recovers file names but not the folder structure. Files with the same names can be renamed during recovery. | |
All programs, except Orion File Recovery, can recover file names and the folder structure. Restorer Ultimate and R-Undelete have the best file recovery parameter set and can recover various NTFS attributes. |
S.M.A.R.T.
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Shows hard drive’s S.M.A.R.T. attributes in a pop-up window. When attempting to work with a drive with bad S.M.A.R.T. data, the program throws a special warning that recommends performing data recover from an image. | |
R-Undelete | 6.0 | S.M.A.R.T. attributes shown in a pop-up window. If bad S.M.A.R.T. data is present, displays a warning message with a recommendation to image the drive and work from the image. | |
Ontrack® EasyRecovery™ Enterprise | 5.0 | Shows hard drive’s S.M.A.R.T. attributes in a special S.M.A.R.T. tab. | |
Orion File Recovery | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
Active@ File Recovery Ultimate Corporate | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
Recover My Files | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
Handy Recovery | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
Stellar Phoenix Windows Data Recovery Home | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
Only three of the evaluated programs have this feature. Restorer Ultimate and R-Undelete not only show the S.M.A.R.T. attributes, they also throw special warnings when the user tries to recover files from a drive with hardware issues. |
File recovery using file signatures (raw file recovery)
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Can be used alone on hard drives and partitions as an alternative file recovery method. Can be disabled, if necessary. The user can specify which file type to search for. The program also supports custom file signatures, which can be added or edited using the built-in file signature editor. User file signatures can be stored in and loaded from a file. | |
Stellar Phoenix Windows Data Recovery Home | 5.0 | This feature exists with a pre-defined file signature set. Supports adding and editing of custom file signatures. | |
Active@ File Recovery Ultimate Corporate | 5.0 | This feature exists with a pre-defined file signature set. The user can select which file types are to be included and add custom file signatures. | |
Recover My Files | 4.5 | This feature exists with a pre-defined file signature set. The user can select which file types are to be included. Can be used alone, as an alternative file recovery method. The raw file size can be limited. | |
Ontrack® EasyRecovery™ Enterprise | 4.5 | This feature exists with a pre-defined file signature set. The user can select which predefined file type is to be included and specify a file size range for found raw files. | |
R-Undelete | 4.5 | This feature exists with a pre-defined file signature set. The user can select which predefined file type is to be included. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.0 | This feature exists with a pre-defined file signature set. The maximum size of files found using file signatures can be specified. | |
Handy Recovery | 4.0 | This feature exists with a pre-defined file signature set. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 4.0 | This feature exists with a pre-defined file signature set. | |
Orion File Recovery | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
All tested programs, except Orion File Recovery, have this feature which is necessary when the file system on the disk is severely damaged. Several programs allow users to select which file types are to be included in the raw file search. In Restorer Ultimate, Stellar Phoenix Windows Data Recovery Home, and Active@File Recovery the user can add and edit custom file signatures. |
Logging
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 5.5 | Very versatile logging. The log can be saved to a file. | |
Ontrack® EasyRecovery™ Enterprise | 5.5 | Very versatile logging. The log can be saved to a file. | |
Stellar Phoenix Windows Data Recovery Home | 4.0 | Standard logging. The log can be saved to a file. | |
Active@ File Recovery Ultimate Corporate | 4.0 | Standard logging. The log can be saved to a file. | |
Recover My Files | 4.0 | Standard logging at various levels: None, Verbose, Debug. The log can be printed. | |
R-Undelete | 3.0 | Logs a list of successfully recovered / failed to recover files. | |
Orion File Recovery | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
Handy Recovery | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 0.0 | We could not find this feature in the program. | |
About half of the programs we evaluated had logging features. Restorer Ultimate and Ontrack® EasyRecovery™ Home have the best logging features, which are equal to professional data recovery software. |
Deep analysis of disks (disk scan)
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Very versatile scan parameters. Disks can be scanned partially and combined with results of several different scans. Scan results may be stored in a file during the scan and loaded later. The user can control bad sector processing and memory usage. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 5.0 | Versatile scan parameter set. Disks can be scanned partially. Scan results are automatically stored in a file after the scan is completed and may be loaded later. | |
Handy Recovery | 4.0 | Some scan parameters can be specified. Scan results are automatically stored in a file after the scan is completed and may be loaded later. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 3.5 | Limited scan parameter set. Scan results are automatically stored in a file after the scan is completed and may be loaded later. Scan results cannot be loaded in the Demo version. | |
Ontrack® EasyRecovery™ Enterprise | 3.0 | Several scan parameters can be specified, including file system to scan, scan area, and bad sector processing. Only scan log can be stored. | |
Active@ File Recovery Ultimate Corporate | 3.0 | Hard drives and logical disks can be scanned. Scan range and file systems can be specified. Scan results can be stored and then loaded later. | |
Recover My Files | 3.0 | Hard drives and logical disks can be scanned. Scan range and file systems can be specified. Scan results can be stored and then loaded later. | |
R-Undelete | 2.5 | No scan parameters can be specified. Scan results may be stored in a file during the scan and loaded later. | |
Stellar Phoenix Windows Data Recovery Home | 2.5 | No scan parameters can be specified. | |
Orion File Recovery | 2.0 | No scan parameters can be specified, except a search for certain files and file groups. Scan can be made in certain folders. Scan results cannot be stored and loaded. | |
All tested programs have this feature which is necessary to recover files from disks with damaged file systems. Most programs allow their users to store and load scan results. Restorer Ultimate and EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard have the best set of scan parameters. |
Logging
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Full logging, with parameter adjustment. | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | Lists failed and successful file recoveries. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.0 | No such feature. | |
Handy Recovery | 4.0 | No such feature. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 2.0 | No such feature. | |
Stellar Phoenix Windows Data Recovery Home | 2.0 | No such feature. | |
Restorer Ultimate has the best logging features, rivaling even professional data recovery software. |
File search, mark for recovery, sorting
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Software features that help users find, sort, and mark files for recovery: “Show only deleted files”, “Show only existing files”, individual file search/mark for recovery, file mask search/mark for recovery, file search for date, file search for size, file search for file ID, file sorting by file extension, file sorting by file timestamp. | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | Software features that help users find, sort, and mark files for recovery: “Show only deleted files”, “Show only existing files”, individual file search/mark for recovery, file mask search/mark for recovery, file search for date, file search for size, file search for file ID, file sorting by file extension, file sorting by file timestamp. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.0 | Software features that help users find, sort, and mark files for recovery: Individual file search/mark for recovery, file mask search/mark for recovery, file search for date, file search for size, file sorting by file extension. | |
Handy Recovery | 4.0 | Software features that help users find, sort, and mark files for recovery: “Show only deleted files”, “Show only existing files”, individual file search/mark for recovery, file mask search/mark for recovery, file search for date, file search for size, file sorting by file extension, file sorting by file timestamp. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 2.0 | Software features that help users find, sort, and mark files for recovery: Individual file search, file mask search, file search for date, file search for size. | |
Stellar Phoenix Windows Data Recovery Home | 2.0 | Software features that help users find, sort, and mark files for recovery: “Show only deleted files”, “Show only existing files”, individual file search, file sorting by file extension, file sorting by file time. | |
Handy Recovery, Restorer Ultimate, and R-Undelete, have the best file search, sorting, and mark for recovery capabilities. |
File recovery using file signatures (raw file recovery)
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Users can add and edit their own file signatures. A built-in file signature editor allows creation of very complex signature combinations. | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | The feature is present with a pre-defined file signature set. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.0 | The user can specify the maximum size of files found using file signatures. | |
Handy Recovery | 4.0 | The feature is present with a predefined file signature set. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 2.0 | The feature is present with a predefined file signature set. | |
Stellar Phoenix Windows Data Recovery Home | 2.0 | Users can add and edit their own file signatures. | |
All tested programs have this feature, which is necessary when the file system on the disk is severely damaged. In Restorer Ultimate and Stellar Phoenix Windows Data Recovery Home, the users can add and edit their own file signatures. |
File recovery parameters
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Recovers file names and folder structure. Recovers hidden attributes, system attributes, alternative data streams for NTFS, security attributes for NTFS. | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | Recovers file names and folder structure. Recovers hidden attributes, system attributes, alternative data streams for NTFS, security attributes for NTFS. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.0 | Recovers file names and folder structure. | |
Handy Recovery | 4.0 | Recovers file names and folder structure. Recovers alternative data streams for NTFS. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 2.0 | Recovers file names and folder structure. | |
Stellar Phoenix Windows Data Recovery Home | 2.0 | Recovers file names and folder structure. | |
Restorer Ultimate and R-Undelete have the best file recovery parameter set. |
Disk parts/regions
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Regions appear as objects that can be processed like regular disks. | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | No such feature. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.0 | Separate disk areas can be imaged. | |
Handy Recovery | 4.0 | Separate disk areas can be scanned. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 2.0 | No such feature. | |
Stellar Phoenix Windows Data Recovery Home | 2.0 | No such feature. | |
Regions or disk parts are useful when it’s necessary to process only a part of disk—for example, only that disk area where a deleted partition might reside. Restorer Ultimate has the best region capabilities. |
Deep analysis of disks (disk scan)
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | A very versatile scan parameter set. Disks can be scanned partially, with combined results of several different scans. Scan results may be stored in a file during the scan and loaded later. | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | No scan parameters can be specified. Scan results may be stored in a file during the scan and loaded later. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.0 | A versatile scan parameter set. Disks can be scanned partially. Scan results are automatically stored in a file after the scan is completed and may be loaded later. | |
Handy Recovery | 4.0 | Some scan parameters can be specified. Scan results are automatically stored in a file after the scan is completed and may be loaded later. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 2.0 | A limited scan parameter set. Scan results are automatically stored in a file after the scan is completed and may be loaded later. Scan results cannot be loaded in the Demo version. | |
Stellar Phoenix Windows Data Recovery Home | 2.0 | No scan parameters can be specified. Scan results cannot be stored. | |
All tested programs have this feature, which is necessary if files have to be recovered from disks with damaged file systems. Restorer Ultimate and EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard have the best set of scan parameters. |
Disk images
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Image types: byte-by-byte and compressed. Parameters specified: compression rate, file split size, password, bad sector processing. The program can scan disks while imaging. | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | Image types: byte-by-byte and compressed. Parameters specified: compression rate, file split size, password, bad sector processing. The program can scan disks while imaging. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.0 | Image types: byte-by-byte and compressed. Parameters specified: compression rate, file split size, password, bad sector processing. | |
Handy Recovery | 4.0 | Image types: byte-by-byte and compressed. Parameters specified: compression rate, file split size. | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 2.0 | No such feature. | |
Stellar Phoenix Windows Data Recovery Home | 2.0 | No such feature. | |
Disk imaging is a very useful feature when working with disks with hardware problems. In this case, the best practice is to create an image of the disk first, and then perform all file recovery tasks from the image. Restorer Ultimate and R-Undelete have the best disk imaging capabilities. They can also scan the disks while creating their images. |
File systems supported for file recovery
Product | Rating | Test Results | |
---|---|---|---|
Restorer Ultimate | 6.0 | Demo: FAT/exFAT, ReFS, NTFS/NTFS5 Pro: All of the above, plus HFS/HFS+, Ext2/3/4fs, and UFS file systems. | |
R-Undelete | 5.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, ReFS. | |
EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard | 4.0 | FAT, NTFS/NTFS5, Ext2/3 (Free version) | |
Handy Recovery | 4.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, HFS/HFS+ | |
MiniTool Power Data Recovery | 2.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5, search for HFS+ and CD/DVD | |
Stellar Phoenix Windows Data Recovery Home | 2.0 | FAT/exFAT, NTFS/NTFS5 | |
Restorer Ultimate and R-Undelete support the best set of file systems for Windows computers, which includes the new emerging ReFS. If necessary, Restorer Ultimate can be upgraded to the Pro version which supports Mac OS and Linux file systems. Handy Recovery doesn’t support ReFS, but supports Mac OS file systems. |